"From a Projected Shortage of up to 11,100 Doctors"…How Did the Annual Increase of 668 Students Come About?
Deliberation Committee Approves Expansion of Medical School Enrollment by Over 3,300 in Five Years
Introduction of an "Educational Capacity Cap" Not Included in Estimation Committee Discussions
The government has finalized a plan to increase medical school enrollment by an annual average of 668 students over the next five years, adding a total of 3,342 prospective doctors. All additional seats will be allocated to 32 medical schools outside Seoul through a regional doctor admission track, and those selected will be required to serve for 10 years at medical institutions in regional areas after graduation.
However, during the seven rounds of discussions at the Health and Medical Policy Deliberation Committee, the estimated shortage of doctors changed from meeting to meeting, and a new criterion of "educational capacity," which had never been discussed at the original Medical Workforce Supply and Demand Estimation Committee, suddenly appeared. This has prompted criticism that the government had already decided on the conclusion and simply forced the numbers to fit.
According to the medical community on the 10th, since the first meeting of the Deliberation Committee, which began in late December last year, the estimated shortage of doctors has repeatedly fluctuated with each round of debate. The Estimation Committee originally submitted 12 models to the Deliberation Committee, combining six demand models and two supply models. Based on these, the projected shortage of doctors in 2040 ranged from 5,704 to 11,136.
However, at the second meeting of the Deliberation Committee held early in the new year, the minimum estimated shortage of doctors was reduced from 5,704 to 5,015. At the third meeting on the 13th of last month, the committee decided to apply the estimation criteria to students entering medical school in the 2027–2031 academic years and to set 2037, when these students will enter the workforce, as the base year for the supply-demand system. Through this process, the estimated shortage of doctors was reduced to a range of 2,530 to 7,261. At the fourth meeting on the 20th of last month, the model with the maximum shortage of 7,261 doctors was excluded at the suggestion of Minister of Health and Welfare Jung Eun-kyeong, and the upper bound of the shortage was lowered again to 4,800.
A week later, at the fifth meeting, members of the Deliberation Committee argued that "models with too many variables are unstable" and, under the banner of "model stability," scrapped "Supply Scenario 2," which had factored in the inflow of graduates from overseas medical schools. As a result, the minimum shortage jumped by 1,732, from 2,530 to 4,262. In the end, at the seventh meeting held that day, the shortage was finalized at 4,724.
At a briefing that day, Minister Jung said, "The Estimation Committee presented 12 models based on various data, and the range was wide, from 1,500 to 7,000," adding, "We said we would respect the estimation results of the committee but make a policy judgment, and we reached a consensus through the meetings."
The controversy grew further at the stage of converting the estimated shortage into an actual increase in enrollment. At the fifth meeting on the 27th of last month, the Ministry of Health and Welfare proposed upper limits on additional enrollment for each university, citing the need to consider the quality of medical education, training conditions, and the capacity of the medical field to absorb new doctors. At that time, for national universities, the ministry set the upper limit at up to 30% above current enrollment for medical schools with a quota of 50 or more students, and up to 50% for those with fewer than 50. For private universities, the upper limit was set at 20% for schools with a quota of 50 or more and 30% for those with fewer than 50.
This was a new criterion that had not been part of the Estimation Committee's work or the previous discussions of the Deliberation Committee. Until then, the committee had been debating annual increases of 732 to 840 students based on the Estimation Committee's scenarios. Once the upper limits based on educational capacity were applied, however, the scale of the proposed increase dropped sharply to about 579 to 585 students per year. In the final round of discussions, it was decided that national universities could increase enrollment by 30% to 100%, depending on their existing quota size, while private universities could increase by 20% to 30%.
At the Deliberation Committee meeting that day, the final size of the increase was determined by a vote. However, one of the committee members, Korean Medical Association President Kim Taekwoo, left the meeting room before the vote on the expansion plan and did not take part. President Kim said, "I cannot help but express deep regret and concern over the government's decision, which is fixated solely on 'numbers' and lacks rational reasoning," and urged, "Immediately conduct a full-scale survey of each medical school to verify whether proper education is actually possible, and recalculate enrollment quotas based on those results."
By contrast, the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions, which is also represented on the Deliberation Committee, reportedly voted against the plan, arguing that "we cannot accept an expansion plan that is smaller than the original supply-demand estimation results." The remaining 18 members of the committee all voted in favor.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Minister Jung said, "In the previous (government-led) process of increasing medical school enrollment, there were criticisms that scientific evidence and democratic procedures were lacking," and added, "This time, we have clearly defined the purpose by applying the regional doctor system to all additional students, and the decision is meaningful in that it is based on scientific evidence and a process of democratic consensus."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.