Ambiguous "violation of duties" clause risks overuse of criminal sanctions
Need to apply presumption of innocence and ease defendants' burden of proof

A proposal has been made to codify the "business judgment rule" and clarify the constituent elements of the crime of breach of trust in order to minimize its adverse effects on corporate management. The argument is that, at a time when global competition in advanced technologies is becoming increasingly fierce, economic criminal penalties, including the crime of breach of trust, must be rationally improved to enhance entrepreneurship and promote investment in new industries.


On the 10th, at a seminar titled "Issues and Improvement Measures for the Crime of Breach of Trust" hosted by the Federation of Korean Industries (hereinafter referred to as FKI), Ahn Taejun, a professor at Hanyang University Law School, pointed out that the ambiguous provisions of the crime of breach of trust undermine the "principle of clarity" and predictability required by the principle of legality under criminal law. The crime of breach of trust refers to an offense in which a person who handles another’s affairs obtains property benefits through acts that violate his or her duties, or causes a third party to obtain such benefits, thereby inflicting loss on the principal.

An Taejun, a professor at Hanyang University School of Law, is giving a presentation at the "Issues and Improvement Measures for the Offense of Breach of Trust" seminar held at FKI Tower on the 10th, hosted by the Federation of Korean Industries. Photo by Kim Jinyoung.

An Taejun, a professor at Hanyang University School of Law, is giving a presentation at the "Issues and Improvement Measures for the Offense of Breach of Trust" seminar held at FKI Tower on the 10th, hosted by the Federation of Korean Industries. Photo by Kim Jinyoung.

View original image

Article 2 of the Civil Act requires that the exercise of rights and the performance of obligations be carried out in good faith, in accordance with the "principle of good faith and sincerity." Professor Ahn viewed the ambiguous provision of "violation of duties" within the breach of trust clause as creating a structure in which violation of obligations under the principle of good faith can itself become a crime, thereby unpredictably expanding the scope of conduct that can constitute breach of trust.


Professor Ahn proposed three legislative alternatives to minimize the adverse effects of the crime of breach of trust on corporate management. The first is the introduction of the business judgment rule. This would establish a new provision stipulating that reasonable decisions made on the basis of sufficient information and without conflicts of interest are not to be regarded as "violations of duties" under the crime of breach of trust.


The second option is the complete abolition of the crime of breach of trust. Under this approach, the offense would be abolished and only those types of conduct that truly require punishment would be specified and legislated as independent constituent offenses. The third option is to refine the constituent elements. Measures discussed include adding a requirement of a "clear purpose," as in Japan, or narrowing the scope of "another’s affairs" through more precise wording.


However, calls to abolish the law itself on the grounds of ambiguity were met with caution. Hong Youngki, vice dean of Korea University Law School, who participated in the discussion, said, "The only offense that deprives or infringes upon another’s 'property benefits' is the crime of breach of trust," adding, "Rather than abolishing the law itself, it is necessary to prepare concrete practical guidelines and apply them strictly to each individual case." According to Vice Dean Hong, if the business judgment rule is treated as a ground for justifying the illegality of breach of trust, the punishability of corporate management activities can be significantly more limited than it is now.


It was also pointed out that in most breach of trust cases, the presumption of innocence is neglected and ex post evaluations are made with a focus on outcomes. Kangwon, a professor in the Department of Business Administration at Sejong University, said, "When businesspeople are indicted for occupational breach of trust, they inevitably have to devote resources and capabilities to self-defense until a final acquittal is reached, and this can lead to a weakening of corporate competitiveness," calling for reforms that minimize criminal intervention in the realm of corporate business judgment and clearly reaffirm the presumption of innocence.

Kim Changbeom, full-time vice chairman of the Korea Economic Association (fifth from the left), and participants are posing for a commemorative photo on the 10th before the "Problems and Improvement Measures of the Crime of Breach of Trust" seminar held at the Federation of Korean Industries Tower, hosted by the Korea Economic Association. Photo by Kim Jinyoung

Kim Changbeom, full-time vice chairman of the Korea Economic Association (fifth from the left), and participants are posing for a commemorative photo on the 10th before the "Problems and Improvement Measures of the Crime of Breach of Trust" seminar held at the Federation of Korean Industries Tower, hosted by the Korea Economic Association. Photo by Kim Jinyoung

View original image

Major countries differ from Korea in how they regulate the crime of breach of trust. In Germany, attempts (incomplete offenses) are not punishable, and there are no aggravated provisions for occupational or special breach of trust. Japan, in addition to intent, requires strict subjective elements such as "the purpose of seeking benefits for oneself or a third party, or of causing loss to the principal." The United States and the United Kingdom have no standalone statutory offense of breach of trust, and even where similar provisions exist, their scope of application is limited.


Ryu Hyukseon, a professor at the KAIST College of Business, said, "Due to the ambiguity of the crime of breach of trust, courts have expanded the interpretation of 'violation of duties' to include so-called 'breach of the principle of good faith,' meaning a 'breach of expected trust,'" and emphasized, "As in Germany and Japan, where the power to punish functions as a last resort to supplement civil control mechanisms, it is necessary in Korea as well to more clearly reset the boundary between criminal and civil liability in relation to the crime of breach of trust."


In his opening remarks, Kim Changbeom, Executive Vice Chairman of FKI, said, "We are at a point where large-scale investment is needed to secure future growth engines such as artificial intelligence (AI), batteries, bio, and future mobility, but due to the crime of breach of trust, business leaders are having difficulty making bold, risk-taking decisions," and stressed, "To resolve uncertainty in corporate management and enhance entrepreneurship, which is the source of innovation, the system governing the crime of breach of trust must be rationally improved."



Kwon Chilseung, head of the Democratic Party of Korea’s Task Force on Rationalizing Economic Criminal Penalties and Civil Liability, said, "We are well aware that the business community’s strongest demand is the clarification of the business judgment rule, and on this point there is virtually no disagreement between the ruling and opposition parties or between the party and the government," and pledged, "Whatever legislative form the reform of the crime of breach of trust may take, it will definitely include protection of normal business judgment from the threat of breach of trust charges."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing