Calling in the top two lowest bidders for "extra negotiations"
In 50 contracts, payments were cut below the winning bid prices

Seojin Saneop Co., Ltd., a mid-sized South Korean auto parts company, has been caught by the Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) for unfair subcontracting practices against small and medium-sized partner companies, including issuing contracts late and further cutting payments below the lowest bid price.

Seojin Saneop building. Seojin Saneop homepage.

Seojin Saneop building. Seojin Saneop homepage.

View original image

On the 10th, the KFTC announced that it had decided to impose a corrective order and a surcharge of 378 million won on Seojin Saneop for its unfair subcontracting practices. According to the KFTC, from 2019 to 2023 Seojin Saneop entered into 50 subcontracting contracts through lowest-price competitive bidding, but then set the subcontract payments at amounts lower than the winning lowest bid, citing reasons such as improving profitability. In particular, the company conducted additional price negotiations with the first- and second-ranked lowest bidders and, without justifiable grounds, reduced the prices they had offered.


The violations of the obligation to issue written contracts were also serious. While commissioning 88 cases of mold manufacturing to 16 subcontractors, Seojin Saneop issued written contracts only after work had already begun, with delays ranging from at least 14 days to as long as 234 days. This directly contravenes the Subcontracting Act, which requires that written contracts be issued before work starts.


Stinginess in the payment process was also confirmed. After receiving the deliverables, Seojin Saneop paid the subcontract amounts more than 60 days later but did not pay its partners the resulting delay interest of about 94 million won, nor other costs such as bill discount fees, totaling approximately 114 million won.


Once the investigation began, Seojin Saneop applied in September last year to initiate a "consent decision" procedure, under which it would voluntarily prepare and implement corrective measures. However, the KFTC rejected this, taking into account the seriousness of the violations and the clarity of the evidence, and finalized sanctions through a formal deliberation.



A KFTC official stated, "We have strictly sanctioned the practice of using superior bargaining power to start transactions without written contracts or to unfairly cut subcontract payments," adding, "We will continue to monitor and crack down on unfair transactions that infringe on the rights and interests of subcontractors."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing