No Refund Claim If You Keep Paying Contributions Even When the "Refund Guarantee" Is Void
Even if a refund-guarantee agreement made at the time of joining a local housing association is void, a member cannot later claim that the association contract itself is void if they have engaged in contradictory conduct, such as continuing to pay their contribution. The Supreme Court held that such a claim violates the principle of good faith. On December 24, the Second Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Kwon Youngjun) reversed the lower court’s judgment in the part unfavorable to the association in the final appeal (Case No. 2025Da216757), which was a lawsuit filed by A against B Local Housing Association seeking the return of unjust enrichment, and remanded the case to the Seoul Central District Court.
[Facts]
B Local Housing Association is a local housing association whose project implementation area covers Dong-gu, Daejeon, and it obtained approval for the establishment of the housing association on October 29, 2021.
On April 27, 2021, A entered into a membership contract with the promotion committee of B Local Housing Association. At that time, A was given a safety-guarantee certificate containing a refund-guarantee clause stating that "if approval for the establishment of the association is not obtained by December 31, 2021, the entire amount already paid will be refunded."
As contributions, A paid 25 million won on April 22, 2021, 40 million won on July 14, 2021, and 38.4 million won on November 1, 2021, for a total of 103.4 million won to the association.
Afterwards, A claimed that the refund-guarantee agreement was void as an act of disposing of common property without a general meeting resolution and that, as a result, the membership contract was rescinded due to mistake, and demanded the return of the contributions.
[Lower Court Rulings]
The court of first instance and the appellate court both held that the refund-guarantee agreement constituted an act of disposing of common property and was therefore void because it had not gone through a general meeting resolution. They further found that A had entered into the contract in the belief that the refund-guarantee agreement was valid, which amounted to a mistake regarding an essential element, and thus ruled that the membership contract was rescinded. They held that Association B must return the contributions to A.
[Supreme Court Ruling]
The Supreme Court reached a different conclusion. It held that the purpose of the local housing association membership contract is to successfully complete the housing construction project and acquire ownership of the newly built apartment. It explained that the refund-guarantee agreement was intended only to minimize loss if that purpose was not achieved, and was not meant to absolutely guarantee the return of the contributions. The key points of the Supreme Court’s reasoning are as follows.
- A’s assertion that the membership contract is void because the refund-guarantee agreement is void, or that the membership contract is rescinded because A was mistaken about the validity of the refund-guarantee agreement, is not permissible as it violates the principle of good faith.
- Even after it had become certain that the refund condition stipulated in the refund-guarantee agreement would not be fulfilled, A not only failed to demand a refund of the contributions from Association B, but also paid a substantial portion of the contributions stipulated in the membership contract in order to achieve the purpose of acquiring ownership of the new apartment.
- In light of A’s payment of contributions, Association B could trust that A wished to maintain the membership contract regardless of whether a refund under the refund-guarantee agreement was possible, and it appears to have proceeded with the housing construction project on that basis. There is a need to protect this reliance by Association B.
- A’s assertion of nullity or rescission for mistake of the membership contract is conduct that contradicts A’s prior payment of contributions, and it would be inequitable and, in light of the concept of justice, unacceptable for Association B and the remaining association members to bear losses corresponding to A’s share of the contributions as a result of A’s inconsistent attitude.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An Jaemyung, Legal Times Reporter
※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.