The Real Opponent Is Not a "Speculative Force"
But the "Speculative Impulse" Within Us All

[Inside Chodong]Real Estate Crusade, What Is It Fighting Against View original image

Although the President has criticized it, from the perspective of an individual or a single household, it has been difficult to find an investment as rational as real estate. At least when limited to the Seoul metropolitan area since industrialization, this has still held true. The speed at which asset values have increased has far outpaced the value of money. Owners could reliably collect rent, and if necessary, they could move in themselves to save on housing costs.


However, when this ingrained belief spreads at a collective level, circumstances change. Each person's rational decisions can combine to produce an irrational outcome for the group. When everyone flocks to one place, a bubble inevitably forms. We have already seen cases where members of society focus solely on real estate, tying up capital that should have gone into productive uses and causing the national economy to falter. Japan's "Lost 30 Years," as well as the structural crisis narrative that emerged in China after years of growth following reform and opening, both have real estate bubbles as direct or indirect causes.


This seems to be the very concern that President Lee Jaemyung has. Last year, even after restricting loans—considered a major cause of rising home prices early in his administration—and designating regulated areas to make transactions more difficult, property prices in prime locations in Seoul continued to soar. After maintaining a general stance on real estate issues around the last presidential election, he suddenly shifted to a more aggressive approach, likely because the "real estate never loses" mentality showed no signs of cracking.


Once he drew his sword, there was no hesitation. At least regarding the real estate issue, a known weakness of the Democratic Party administration, some predicted that he would keep a low profile until the upcoming local elections in June, but he chose to confront it head-on. President Lee’s focus is primarily on owners of multiple properties. The argument is that buying homes you don't live in amounts to speculation. He applies subtle pressure while also trying to persuade with kind words.


Even when career civil servants hesitated over the suspension of the capital gains tax surcharge, President Lee made it clear, saying, "The answer was already decided last year," indicating that the surcharge would be imposed. He also delivered a series of resolute messages, including, "There is no government that can defeat the market, but no market that can defeat the government," "If you do not weigh immediate gains or losses, there are plenty of policy tools available," and "We will stop ruinous real estate speculation 'by any means necessary.'" It would not be an exaggeration to call this a real estate crusade.


In terms of drawing clear battle lines, the President himself—or the government as a whole—taking on speculative multi-home owners is a scenario that makes sense. This is a character that many of us might recognize from our own surroundings. However, there remains a lingering sense of discomfort. I am not convinced that simply binding the hands and feet of multi-home owners and creating systems that force the sale of unused properties will be enough to break a real estate dogma that has been built over decades. After all, dogma is, by its nature, an area where rational judgment and belief do not operate.


This is closely linked to a very real desire: "I want to make money from real estate." Even if new systems or policies target certain groups or classes, I believe it will not be easy to control the desires of the majority of society. There may even be backlash from those who claim this is akin to "kicking away the ladder," as they are now unable to do what was once common practice. Nevertheless, since the President has raised the issue, I hope this becomes an opportunity for each of us to confront and grapple with the desires reflected in real estate. After all, the true opponent in this crusade is not just the "speculative forces," but the speculative mindset inherent in all of us.



Choi Daeyeol, Construction and Real Estate Department


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing