Severe injuries to neighbors due to poor management of fierce dogs
Four-year prison sentence finalized
"A 'Beware of Dog' sign alone is not enough"

The Supreme Court has finalized a prison sentence for a dog owner in a case where un-leashed, fierce dogs attacked neighboring residents and delivery workers, causing human casualties on four separate occasions in a single year. The ruling clarifies that a dog owner’s liability for negligence is not exempted simply because a "Beware of Dog" sign has been installed, if no substantive safety measures are taken.

View of the Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News

View of the Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News

View original image

According to the legal community on February 10, the Third Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Park Youngjae) upheld the lower court’s ruling that sentenced dog owner A to four years in prison in the final appeal trial on charges of violating the Animal Protection Act and causing injury by gross negligence. The lower court’s decision to confiscate two fierce dogs was also maintained.


A, who was raising two fierce dogs, including Dogo Canarios, in Goheung-gun, Jeollanam-do, was brought to trial on charges of causing human casualties by neglecting his duty of care, such as failing to put leashes and muzzles on the dogs. An investigation found that, over the course of 2024 alone, the dogs ran out of the house on four occasions and indiscriminately attacked neighboring residents and parcel delivery workers. In particular, one of the victims suffered severe injuries all over the body, including the genitals, and fell into a life-threatening condition due to acute sepsis.


During the trial, A argued that he had done his best to prevent accidents, such as by installing a "Beware of Dog" sign around the house. However, the court of first instance sentenced A to four years in prison and ordered the confiscation of the two fierce dogs, stating that "he did not take substantive measures, such as installing a solid locking device to prevent the dogs from escaping or putting them on a leash."


The appellate court also acknowledged A’s negligence and upheld the sentence imposed by the first-instance court. However, it partially modified the ruling to exclude one of the two seized fierce dogs (a white Dogo Canario), which had died during the trial, from the scope of confiscation. The court stated, "Because of the defendant’s poor management, the victim stood at the brink of life and death, and the nature of the crime is extremely serious."



The Supreme Court found no misinterpretation of the law in these lower-court decisions and dismissed A’s appeal. It stated that "it is clear that the defendant’s gross negligence, stemming from his failure to fulfill his duty to prevent accidents, caused the incident," and thus finally confirmed the four-year prison sentence imposed by the lower court.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing