“Since We Are Integrating, We Should Elect a Single Superintendent” vs.
“Educational Autonomy Should Remain at the Regional Level, With Multiple Superintendents”
Experts Warn of “Lack of Related Discussion... Need for a Deliberative Process”

With the June local elections approaching, the method of electing superintendents of education has emerged as a potential flashpoint in the debate over administrative integration. One side argues that, since administrative districts will be merged, the superintendent should also be elected as a single, unified position. The other side contends that, separate from administrative integration, elections should continue to be held under the existing system of multiple superintendents at the current regional level. While the political community, led by the ruling party, is pushing to pass a special act on administrative integration within February, critics say that in the rush to move things forward, there has been insufficient deliberation on educational autonomy.


According to the education community on the 9th, since last month the National Assembly has hosted a series of forums and meetings under the theme of “Administrative Integration and Educational Autonomy.” At events organized respectively by the Korean Association for Education Law and the Korean Society for Educational Administration, experts voiced a shared concern that, if the transition to a “super-regional administrative system” focuses solely on administrative efficiency, educational autonomy could be left in a vacuum. Analysts say that, in particular, the lack of such in-depth discussion underlies the divergent positions on how superintendents should be elected in different regions such as Gwangju-Jeonnam and Daejeon-Chungnam.


Kim Youngrok, governor of Jeollanam-do, is attending the "Gwangju-Jeonnam Administrative Integration Provincial Governors-Superintendents Four-Party Meeting" held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building in Seoul on the 14th, and after signing the joint agreement with Kang Gijeong, mayor of Gwangju Metropolitan City, Kim Daejung, superintendent of education for Jeollanam-do, and Lee Jeongseon, superintendent of education for Gwangju, is posing for a commemorative photo. Jeollanam-do

Kim Youngrok, governor of Jeollanam-do, is attending the "Gwangju-Jeonnam Administrative Integration Provincial Governors-Superintendents Four-Party Meeting" held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building in Seoul on the 14th, and after signing the joint agreement with Kang Gijeong, mayor of Gwangju Metropolitan City, Kim Daejung, superintendent of education for Jeollanam-do, and Lee Jeongseon, superintendent of education for Gwangju, is posing for a commemorative photo. Jeollanam-do

View original image

In Gwangju-Jeonnam, greater weight is being placed on adopting a “unified superintendent” system. On the 4th, at their respective plenary sessions of extraordinary meetings, the Gwangju Metropolitan Council and the Jeollanam-do Provincial Council passed motions to hear opinions on “Gwangju-Jeonnam Administrative Integration,” laying the groundwork for the National Assembly to pass the special act in February. Previously, the governors and superintendents of Gwangju and Jeonnam had reached an agreement through a four-party meeting to integrate not only administrative affairs but also education. The aim is to unify educational administration as well, thereby enhancing policy continuity.


However, some in the education sector warn that the powers of a unified superintendent could become excessively concentrated and argue that a special provision is needed to establish an “education assembly” as a kind of check-and-balance mechanism. Teachers’ organizations and civic groups, including the Gwangju branch of the Korean Teachers and Education Workers Union, say that demands to strengthen educational autonomy are erupting amid the discussion on administrative integration, and they warn in particular that special provisions in the special act allowing the establishment of special-purpose high schools and autonomous private high schools could exacerbate educational disparities within the region. They point out that, if decisions are made without a proper process of deliberation, the result could instead be side effects such as greater confusion in schools and intensified conflict between regions after integration.


Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

By contrast, in Daejeon-Chungnam, calls for electing multiple superintendents are growing louder. Prospective candidates for superintendent in Daejeon and Chungnam argue that even if administrative integration is launched, the education sector should operate under a “multiple-superintendent system.” They say it is unrealistic for a single superintendent to be responsible for both “metropolitan-type education” and “education in agricultural, fishing, and rural areas.” They stress that Daejeon and Chungnam are regions that require completely different educational approaches, and they are calling for the special act to include special provisions on educational autonomy to maintain the administrative and fiscal independence of the two offices of education, as well as to reflect a multiple-superintendent system under which each region elects its own superintendent.



Ultimately, as opinions diverge over educational autonomy, there is growing support for the view that the special act on administrative integration requires more in-depth discussion. At a National Assembly debate held on the 2nd, Professor Park Sujeong of Chungnam National University advised that step-by-step policy implementation is needed through research, deliberation, and pilot applications. Kim Beomju, a researcher at the National Assembly Research Service, suggested that policymakers should undertake a multifaceted review by broadly gathering opinions from stakeholders and experts.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing