[Reading Science] The Freedom and Right to Fail in Research View original image

The phrase "Do not be afraid of failure" has recently become a cliché in the science and technology community. President Lee Jaemyung also emphasized researchers' "freedom and right to fail" in a public setting, saying, "So what if you fail? Accumulated failures become assets for success." However, the reality researchers actually experience is different. There is still a wide gap between rhetoric and制度.


Although policy-level declarations that failure will be acknowledged have increased, the制度that supports the lives and research of scientists after failure has not been sufficiently established. Researchers still continue their work while constantly being conscious of the next project, the next evaluation, and the next performance. Failure is accepted rhetorically as "part of learning," but in reality it remains a burden that makes them worry about the next research grant, rather than becoming an experience that helps them prepare for the next study.


Within the domestic research community, moves to see failure in a different light are gradually emerging. At KAIST, a "Failed Project Contest" is held to disclose failed projects and share the lessons learned from them among researchers. Such attempts are meaningful in helping the research community naturally accept failure, but they still remain at the level of cultural experiments within research circles.


The real problem lies in the evaluation and support structure. The selection of research projects, financial support, and personnel evaluations still rely heavily on quantitative indicators such as the number of papers, citation indices, and the size of research funding secured. Within this structure, it is difficult to reveal experiences of failure. Failure functions as a factor that destabilizes an individual researcher's career.


The structural problems of Korea's research support system are also evident in recent indicators. According to recent reports, the success rate of national research and development (R&D) projects in Korea is still assessed at over 90%. The scientific community views this high success rate less as the result of performance management, and more as a reflection of a structure in which research with a possibility of failure is filtered out from the support stage.


When we look overseas, the problems of this structure become even clearer. The U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH), regarded as one of the most influential research institutions in the world, has recorded an average annual success rate of only about 18% over the past decade in its Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) and Small Business Technology Transfer (STTR) programs. The NIH has intentionally maintained this low success rate of 15–20% and concentrated resources on research with a high likelihood of failure. High-risk research accumulated under this structure led to tangible成果during the COVID-19 pandemic, helping accelerate the development of mRNA vaccines.


This problem awareness has been consistently raised within Korean academia as well. Distinguished scholars at KAIST and Pohang University of Science and Technology have pointed out at academic events that "failure is the essence of science, but we do not have institutional mechanisms to accumulate failure as knowledge." If failures are not recorded and shared as research assets and reflected in the design of subsequent studies, then statements such as "We acknowledge failure" will inevitably remain empty slogans.


A culture that truly accepts failure cannot be created by declarations alone. Failure should not be dismissed simply as research without results; instead, we must evaluate the context in which it occurred and what lessons it left behind, and then use this knowledge in subsequent research and talent development. If制度does not guarantee researchers a certain period of time and opportunity to devote themselves to research even after failure, failure will function as a signal to stop doing research.



In the current reality, statements that failure will be acknowledged are repeated, but the structure that allows researchers who have experienced failure to continue their work and careers remains fragile. For policy to genuinely embrace failure, evaluation criteria and support systems must be redesigned. Only when research can continue even after failure will failure truly become an asset for innovation.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing