"Severely Undervalued"...Targeting Corporate Governance Issues
"Enhancing Value Through More Efficient Capital Allocation and Increased Shareholder Returns"

On February 6, domestic activist fund Align Partners Asset Management stated, "We have sent an open letter to the board of directors of DB Insurance (DB Sonbo) to enhance shareholder value, and have submitted shareholder proposals to appoint two independent directors as audit committee members elected separately and to reinstate the Internal Transactions Committee."


Through this open shareholder letter, Align Partners proposed eight items aimed at enhancing shareholder value, and requested a public written response and a re-announcement of a value-up plan by March 6. It then submitted shareholder proposals to the 59th Annual General Meeting of Shareholders, scheduled to be held next month, for the reinstatement of the Internal Transactions Committee and the appointment of two independent directors who would serve as members of the Audit Committee. Align Partners has been investing in the company since January last year and currently holds approximately a 1.9% stake.


Align Sends Open Letter to DB Insurance Proposing Appointment of Two Audit Committee Members View original image

Align Partners pointed out that DB Insurance is "severely undervalued in the market despite its strong performance." Although it has shown solid profitability, including ranking second in the industry in terms of consolidated net income in 2024, its price-earnings ratio (PER) stands at only 5.4 times. This is significantly lower than the average of 10.6 times for comparable domestic non-life insurers such as Meritz Financial Group and Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance, and the average of 14.1 times for major overseas insurers.


It also emphasized that the adjusted price-to-book ratio (PBR), calculated based on embedded capital including the Contractual Service Margin (CSM) under IFRS 17, is only 0.40 times, meaning the current market capitalization is trading at roughly a 60% discount to embedded capital.


As reasons for the undervaluation, it cited inefficient capital allocation, weak shareholder returns, and pervasive related-party transactions involving the controlling shareholder, framing them as corporate governance issues. DB Insurance's return on required capital (ROR) is 21.2%, which lags behind Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance (25.8%) and Meritz Fire & Marine Insurance (37.6%), and its shareholder return ratio in 2024 is also 22.1%, showing a substantial gap compared with competitors.


From a governance perspective, the relatively low ownership stake in DB Insurance (20.9%) compared with the controlling family’s 47.8% stake in DB Inc. was flagged as a problem. This structure is said to create incentives to transfer wealth through internal transactions rather than dividends. In fact, the cumulative amount of internal transactions, mainly no-bid IT (information technology) service contracts, reaches 602.0 billion won, and trademark royalty payments amount to 220.3 billion won.


Align Partners proposed reinstating the Internal Transactions Committee in order to restore the board’s independent monitoring and oversight function. It also recommended two candidates as independent directors to be elected as audit committee members: former Samsung Active Asset Management CEO Min Sua and former Samjeong KPMG partner Choi Heungbeom.



Lee Changhwan, CEO of Align Partners, said, "DB Insurance is the second-largest non-life insurer in Korea, but its undervaluation persists due to inefficient capital allocation, the lowest level of shareholder returns in the industry, and opaque, controlling-shareholder-centric corporate governance. Fundamental changes are needed to normalize shareholder value."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing