Accomplice in 1982 shooting acquitted after appeal
Court: "Witness testimonies conflict... insufficient proof of guilt"

A 100-year-old Indian man who had been sentenced to life imprisonment as an accomplice in a murder case that occurred in 1982 has been acquitted 42 years after the crime. The court pointed to decades-long procedural delays and insufficient evidence, ruling that a trial held so late could reduce justice to a mere ritual.

Gavel image. Not related to the article. Pixabay

Gavel image. Not related to the article. Pixabay

View original image

According to Indian daily the Times of India (TOI) and other local media on the 6th, the Allahabad High Court in the northern Indian state of Uttar Pradesh acquitted Dhani Ram on January 21 of charges related to murder.


The case began in 1982 when a dispute over land escalated into a shooting, leaving one person dead. Maiku, identified as the main perpetrator who fired the gun, fled at the time and his whereabouts remain unknown to this day.


Ram and Sati Deen, who were indicted on the grounds that they had been with Maiku, were each sentenced in 1984 to life imprisonment. Ram appealed immediately after sentencing and was released on bail, while Deen died during the appeal process.


As a result, Ram, the only surviving defendant among the three indicted as accomplices, received a final acquittal in this trial, which was held 42 years after he was charged. The defense argued that there were only indications that Ram had abetted the crime, and that he had not fired the gun himself. The prosecution opposed the acquittal.


In its 23-page judgment, the court noted that the statements of the two witnesses presented by the prosecution conflicted with each other, and that some facts were missing even from the police incident report. It further held that the prosecution had failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.


The court also stated that, due to the long procedural delay, holding the trial so late and imposing full criminal liability on a defendant in the twilight of his life risked turning justice into a mere formality. It stressed that the anxiety and social stigma the defendant likely suffered over several decades should also be taken into account in the decision.



The ruling has triggered a wave of criticism on local online comment boards and social media (SNS), where users pointed to the inefficiency of India’s judicial system and delays in reform. One commenter on the TOI article sarcastically suggested creating awards such as "Worst Judge Award" and "Worst Lawyer Award" for judges and lawyers, criticizing the slow pace of judicial reform. Another user argued that the judiciary should bear responsibility for the prolonged delay in the trial.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing