Civilian Killed by Military and Police During the Korean War
Even if a "Death Sentence Judgment" Is Later Discovered
A Truth-Verification Petition Cannot Be Dismissed Without Execution Records

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The court has ruled that even if a belatedly discovered "death sentence judgment" exists for a civilian who had already been recognized as a victim killed by the military and police during the Korean War, a petition for truth verification must not be dismissed if there is no record of the sentence actually being carried out.


According to the legal community on February 8, the 8th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge Yang Soonjoo) ruled partially in favor of the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by Mr. A seeking to overturn the decision to dismiss his objection against the Truth and Reconciliation Commission.


Mr. A's father and uncle were determined to have been killed by the military and police in Daejeon in 1950 during the Korean War on suspicion of involvement with the National Guidance League, and in November 2023 the Truth and Reconciliation Commission issued a decision verifying the truth of their case. This meant that the state had officially acknowledged that they were illegally harmed by state authority.


However, after that, the Commission found a judgment stating that Mr. A's uncle had been sentenced to death in January 1951 by the High Military Court for violating the National Security Act. The Commission concluded that, contrary to its original decision, Mr. A's uncle had survived until 1951 and that cases with final court judgments are excluded from the scope of truth verification, and therefore it revoked its previous decision and dismissed the petition. Mr. A filed an administrative lawsuit, arguing that this entire disposition was unlawful.


The court first held that the disposition revoking the previous truth-verification decision itself was lawful. In light of the judgment and prison records discovered after the fact, it was confirmed that the previously recognized time, place, and cause of Mr. A's uncle's death differed from the facts.


However, the court found it unlawful to dismiss the truth-verification petition itself. The panel stated, "The judgment in question omits the reasoning, and no records have been found concerning a death warrant for execution of the sentence or the handling of the body," adding, "In the prison register, his release is recorded as due to death, not release by execution of a death sentence, so it is difficult to conclude definitively that he died as a result of the sentence being carried out."



The court went on to say, "Considering that around 1950 many civilians were mistakenly identified and summarily executed or brought before military courts, the content of the petition cannot be deemed clearly false," and held, "The Commission should have reinvestigated the cause of death and the illegality involved, and then newly decided whether to verify the truth."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing