Head Office Supply Price Margins, or "Price-Margin Franchise Fees"
Not Specified in Contracts, Triggering Frequent Disputes with Franchisees
"Must Be Clearly Stated in Contracts... Creating a Fair Business Environment"

To reduce disputes over so-called "hidden profits" that franchisors receive from franchisees in the franchise market, known as price-margin franchise fees, the Seoul Metropolitan Government has stepped in.

File photo from the Franchise Startup Expo. Photo by Kim Hyunmin kimhyun81@

File photo from the Franchise Startup Expo. Photo by Kim Hyunmin kimhyun81@

View original image

According to the Seoul Metropolitan Government on February 6, an analysis of disclosure documents registered with the city as of 2024 showed that among 1,992 brands that generated sales, 47.9% (955 brands) had price-margin franchise fees. The city analyzed that "the collection of price-margin franchise fees is not limited to specific business types but appears widely across franchise businesses as a whole."


A price-margin franchise fee is the margin generated when a franchisor purchases raw materials at a low price and supplies them to franchisees at a higher price. It is one of the main sources of revenue for franchisors, but franchisees find it difficult to identify, creating an information asymmetry problem. If it is imposed excessively, the burden on franchisees increases, so it is legally required to be clearly stated in the disclosure document.


However, the current standard franchise agreement only stipulates traditional forms of consideration such as initial franchise fees and royalties, and does not contain any explicit clause regarding price-margin franchise fees, which are the actual profits generated in the process of supplying raw and subsidiary materials. As a result, information related to price-margin franchise fees is not reflected in franchise agreements, and critics have pointed out that there is a lack of contractual basis when disputes arise.


In response, the Seoul Metropolitan Government has moved to improve the system in order to structurally prevent disputes over price-margin franchise fees between franchisors and franchisees, and to establish a fair trade order across franchise businesses. Using the recent Supreme Court ruling related to Pizza Hut's price-margin franchise fees as a momentum, the city recommended that the Korea Fair Trade Commission revise the standard franchise agreement to encourage a clear contractual relationship between franchisors and franchisees.


In its ruling on Pizza Hut's price-margin franchise fees, the Supreme Court stated that "it is difficult to regard the mere entry in the disclosure document as indicating a contractual agreement on the payment of price-margin franchise fees." Accordingly, the Court established the legal principle that a franchisor must obtain explicit agreement in the contract in order to collect price-margin franchise fees. In particular, it made clear that the practice of passing on costs not specified in the contract to franchisees must be strictly restricted.


The Seoul Metropolitan Government has proposed to the Korea Fair Trade Commission that explicit clauses on price-margin franchise fees be newly added to the standard franchise agreements for 13 business categories.


The proposed amendment includes specific improvement measures to clearly reveal price-margin franchise fees at the contract stage. The main content is to define the concept of "price-margin franchise fee" in Article 2 (Definition of Terms) of the standard franchise agreement. In addition, the provisions on continuing franchise fees in the standard franchise agreement would be revised to specify concrete contract terms, including: whether price-margin franchise fees are collected; the method of calculation and the amount or rate; and the cost-sharing structure and the possibility of changes regarding price-margin franchise fees.


Meanwhile, the Seoul Metropolitan Government expects that clearly specifying price-margin franchise fees in the standard franchise agreement will resolve information asymmetry between franchisors and franchisees and provide an institutional foundation to prevent potential disputes from the contract stage.



Kim Myungseon, Director of the Fair Economy Division at the Seoul Metropolitan Government, said, "Since price-margin franchise fees are an important cost factor in franchise businesses, it is most important that they are fully explained and clearly agreed upon at the contract stage," adding, "The Seoul Metropolitan Government will continue to create a fair franchise business environment in which franchisors and franchisees can coexist and prosper together."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing