The More the Government Intervenes, the More the Market Pushes Back
The Government Should Set Direction, Not Prices

[Insight & Opinion] Can the Market Really Never Beat the Government? View original image


President Lee Jaemyung wrote on his social networking service (SNS), "There is no government that can beat the market, but there is also no market that can beat the government." Logically, the first and second parts do not fit together. If neither the market nor the government can beat the other, does that mean they end in a draw? What the president really wants to say is almost certainly contained in the latter part: a warning not to take the government lightly. But is it really true that the market cannot beat the government?


In fact, we already know the answer. At least in our country, there is no memory of the government's real estate policy ever having beaten the market. During the Roh Moo-hyun administration, which vowed to overhaul the system so that making money through real estate speculation would become completely impossible, apartment prices in Seoul rose by 56%. Under the Moon Jae-in administration, which mobilized almost every possible policy tool to rein in the real estate market, the median price of apartments in Seoul jumped from 600 million won in 2017 to 1.2 billion won in 2021.


It is not strange that the government cannot beat the market. Above all, it is because of information asymmetry. The government does not possess more information than the market. The market is the outcome of countless participants deciding how to allocate resources through the signal of prices. When the government tries to directly control outcomes, it is like switching off the traffic lights. Yet it is impossible for the government to grasp the preferences and resources of all market participants and then draw up a perfect plan. There is also the problem of time lags. It takes time for a policy to be decided, implemented, and then show results. In the meantime, market conditions change. It is also difficult for the government to quickly correct wrong decisions. The market is often compared to a river and the government to a dam. A dam can control the flow of water and prevent floods, but it can neither block nor eliminate the river itself forever. If too much water accumulates in the dam, the floodgates must eventually be opened. If not, the dam will collapse. The failed defense of the British pound and the collapse of fixed exchange rate regimes during the Asian financial crisis are representative examples. The government may be able to beat the market temporarily, but over the long term it inevitably loses.


Saying that the government cannot beat the market should not be taken to mean that any form of government intervention is meaningless. Markets often fail. The social values that markets overlook must, of course, be protected by the government. Ultimately, the strength of the government lies in its ability to design the conditions under which markets can function and to implement that design. It is the government’s role, through policy, to shape market structures and to define the conditions of supply and demand. When the government focuses on the rules through structural design, the market adapts within that framework. In fact, a competent government does not try to fight the market. What matters in reality is a clear division of roles. If the market performs calculation and choice, the government must provide rules and stability. Of course, if the market tries to wholly replace the government, crises will arise.


But that does not mean the government can replace the market either. Since the president is unlikely to change his mind, a reform of the real estate tax system will probably begin after the local elections. The comprehensive real estate holding tax, which was eased under the Yoon Suk Yeol administration, will soon return to the level seen under the Moon Jae-in administration. However, prices should be the outcome of policy, not its target. Government power is effective when it acts as a referee that sets the rules of the game correctly and enforces those rules fairly. When the government tries to control outcomes directly, the market inevitably exacts a price in some other way. The rent cap in Berlin, Germany, which was intended to rein in soaring monthly rents, led to a sharp decline in supply. The government is effective when it plays the role of setting the "direction," but fails when it tries to determine the "price" itself. The same holds true for both real estate and exchange rates.



Kim Sangcheol, economic commentator


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing