First-instance fine of 15 million won overturned
Ruling delivered 10 years after start of appeal

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Yang Seung-oh, who was brought to trial on charges of violating the Public Official Election Act after raising allegations of draft-dodging against the late former Seoul Mayor Park Won-soon's son, Park Jushin (a professor in the Department of Architecture at Korea University), was acquitted on appeal. This ruling came 10 years after the trial began in 2016.


On the 4th, the Criminal Division 6-3 of the Seoul High Court (Presiding Judges Lee Yesl, Choi Eunjeong, and Jeong Jaeo) found Yang not guilty of the charge of violating the Public Official Election Act in connection with his raising of draft-dodging allegations. In 2016, the court of first instance had determined that it was clear that Park had personally undergone the medical examination and sentenced Yang to a fine of 15 million won.


Yang was indicted on charges of raising allegations of draft-dodging by Park in order to prevent then-Mayor Park from being re-elected ahead of the June 2014 local elections. After enlisting in the Air Force in August 2011, Park was sent home due to pain in his right thigh, and he later submitted to the Military Manpower Administration X-ray and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans taken at a hospital, based on which he received a Grade 4 classification in December that year.


When some in political circles at the time raised the so-called "switched MRI" suspicion, Park underwent a public verification at Severance Hospital in 2012, in which 10 participants, including reporters covering Seoul City Hall, took part. However, Yang claimed that the examination in question was a "proxy examination."


The court stated, "Given that ordinary citizens could not take part in Park's public verification process, and considering the reversal in the time stamps of the MRI scans, if there were sufficient grounds to reasonably believe the suspicions were true, then even if those suspicions later prove unfounded, freedom of expression must not be chilled," adding, "We also took into account that, as former Mayor Park was elected mayor, the conduct in question does not appear to have had a significant impact on the actual election result, and that former Mayor Park's side has expressed that it does not wish to see punishment imposed."



The appellate proceedings in this case were delayed due to Park's refusal to appear as a witness and his stay overseas, and thus concluded a full 10 years after the first-instance judgment.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing