Illegal Distribution of Pay-as-You-Throw Bags: The Problem Was "Open-Source Codes"
Nationwide Local Governments Face "Loopholes in Existing Pay-As-You-Throw Bag Distribution Systems"... Some Are Already Responding
Tampering and Forgery Vulnerabilities in Open-Source-Based Pay-As-You-Go Codes such as Barcode, PDF417, and QR Codes
View original imageThere is growing criticism that pay-as-you-throw garbage bags and pay-as-you-throw authentication stickers used by local governments nationwide are structurally vulnerable to forgery, illegal copying, and illegal distribution.
Most local governments use distribution management methods based on QR codes, PDF417, EAN-13 barcodes, and simple stickers. However, these methods have a critical weakness: the code generation and decoding algorithms are open-source, which leaves them completely defenseless against copying and reuse.
Anyone can illegally manufacture such items quite easily. One only needs to download a free app that scans the genuine authentication QR codes, PDF417, or barcodes already printed on existing pay-as-you-throw bags, read the code, then paste the extracted code data into a publicly accessible code-generation website. This process creates a security code that effectively "neutralizes genuine-product authentication."
Experts point out that "using open-source-based codes on pay-as-you-throw bags does not ensure the security of the codes themselves, and at any time this can lead to administrative failure such as tax revenue losses and a decline in credibility due to the distribution of counterfeit products," adding that "they are practically close to useless."
Therefore, for pay-as-you-throw bags produced by local governments, it is desirable to adopt a proprietary (closed-source) code system that production managers can issue independently. For example, Voiceye codes used in government security documents, or URCODE and Digimarc codes specialized for particular industries, can serve as strong alternatives.
In the case of URCODE, the code is thin enough to be applied without issue even to printers with small nozzles (such as CIJ printers), which also reduces printing costs. As a closed-source system with no publicly available generator or decoder, forgery or tampering is, by design, impossible.
Furthermore, in order to copy a URCODE printed on an existing product, a counterfeiter would have to scan the entire URCODE image. This process requires post-processing and re-editing for printing to remove distortions or noise generated during scanning. To evade monitoring and distribution-tracking through scan-data collection, counterfeiters may try to duplicate as many different serials as possible. However, this process is cumbersome and carries a high risk of detection, so it is reasonable to expect a strong deterrent effect against illegal copying, which entails both higher duplication costs and greater risk.
Existing metered codes are vulnerable to forgery; URCODE can block distribution through real-time authentication using closed-source technology.
View original imageIn addition, the URCODE service platform operates an integrated logistics management system spanning production plants, logistics centers, and retail outlets. It provides a total solution tailored to local governments' pay-as-you-throw logistics management, including integrated production-status monitoring for local governments, inventory tracking, ordering functions for retailers, genuine-product authentication history for consumers, and large waste-sticker services.
Against this backdrop, some local governments are taking preemptive action by adopting approaches different from existing methods. Incheon City in Gyeonggi Province is already operating a system in which each individual pay-as-you-throw bag is assigned a unique proprietary (closed-source) code with enhanced security, allowing full management of the production, distribution, and usage stages.
This method enables individual identification at the single-bag level, making it possible to block the distribution of illegally manufactured or copied bags. It can be applied at production plants without additional cost, and verification can be done with existing smartphones rather than dedicated terminals, which is seen as keeping administrative burdens low.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Pay-as-you-throw garbage bags are a form of value-bearing security issued by each local government and are an important good in citizens' daily lives. To prevent the distribution of counterfeit pay-as-you-throw bags that exploit the weaknesses of existing open-source security, improving the management of these bags is essential. To enhance administrative credibility, each local government needs to prepare counterfeit-response strategies and innovate its administrative procedures.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.