[Chip People] "Cracks Are Widening in the HBM Super-Boom... SK Hynix, Samsung, and Micron Will Form a Three-Strong System"
Interview with Semiconductor and AI Expert Kyung Heekwon
Memory Super Boom Driven by Replacement Cycle and AI Boom
AI Emerging as a New U.S.-Led Hegemonic Device
Memory and Foundry Landscape Shaken...Global Order in Flux
Although the memory semiconductor market is enjoying an unprecedented boom thanks to the artificial intelligence (AI) supercycle, there is an emerging assessment that fissures are rapidly forming in the high-bandwidth memory (HBM) market long dominated by SK Hynix. Explosive AI-driven demand is instead widening the door of opportunity for latecomers, and with Samsung Electronics and Micron launching an aggressive pursuit backed by technology and capital, analysts expect the market structure to be rapidly reshaped into a "three-strong system."
Kwon Kyunghee, a research fellow at the Korea Institute for Industrial Economics and Trade, stressed in an interview with The Asia Business Daily at the Sejong National Research Complex on the 2nd that structural changes in the memory market are inevitable. He said, "HBM has been led by SK Hynix, but we are now in a phase where demand exceeds supply capacity," adding, "As this year passes, there is a possibility that the HBM market will diversify into a structure of 3-to-3-to-3 shares among SK Hynix, Samsung Electronics, and Micron."
Kwon Kyunghee, a research fellow at the Korea Institute for Industrial Economics and Trade, is being interviewed by The Asia Business Daily. Sejong = Yun Dongju reporter
View original imageHe explained, "With the AI boom, the unit prices of all DRAM products have surged explosively, so cost competitiveness per unit through capacity (production capability) no longer carries significant meaning," and added, "Traditional unit price competitiveness no longer works, and the market has instead become favorable to the challengers." In particular, regarding Micron, he emphasized that since its acquisition of Elpida, the combination of multi-site research facilities and the impact of U.S. subsidies has rapidly strengthened its presence.
Kwon said, "While Samsung and SK are continuing their process race in the 10-nanometer (1 nm = one-billionth of a meter) range, Micron is said to be jumping straight to the 9-nanometer range, which makes it a 'bloody fight'." He also drew attention to the growth of the application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC) accelerator market rather than the standalone graphics processing unit (GPU) market. "By 2029, the ASIC accelerator market will chase up to 90 billion to 100 billion dollars," he said. "It means that a market of the same scale as today will emerge once more within three years." He added, "The key issue is not who supplied how much volume to Nvidia, but, as HBM standards become more advanced, who is the first to mass-produce products with higher bandwidth and stability."
In the long term, Kwon believes that a relatively favorable structure could form for Samsung Electronics. This is because, as HBM generations become more advanced, the importance of foundry processes grows in the packaging domain, including interposers. He said, "With each new generation, the importance of foundry processes increases," adding, "It becomes a structure where the player with the production and development stamina to withstand large-scale investments gains the upper hand."
He also projected that the foundry market will move away from the single structure centered on Taiwan's TSMC that has persisted for decades and shift into a phase of diversification. With changes in the international political environment, the rise of AI, and the logic of security and sovereignty intersecting, he assessed that opportunities are opening up for latecomers such as Samsung Electronics and Intel. "The fundamental backdrop for the favorable conditions that allowed TSMC to grow, namely the worldview and international political strategy of Western leadership and the cost structure shaped by tariff and non-tariff barriers, has all collapsed," he said. "The AI boom has thrown the doors wide open for latecomers."
"AI is a hegemonic device"...The U.S. 'pushes ahead even if it fails'
Kyung Heekwon, a research fellow at the Korea Institute for Industrial Economics and Trade, is posing after finishing an interview with The Asia Business Daily. Sejong=Photo by Yun Dongju
View original imageHe believes that the global boom in AI investment is underpinned by U.S.-led military and geopolitical "deterrence." Just as there is a theory that the advent of nuclear weapons has deterred large-scale wars, AI is likewise being perceived as a new hegemonic device that blocks interstate conflict itself. He said, "The United States has a sense of crisis that if it falls behind in the AI race, its national capabilities could be constrained," adding, "For this reason, a logic has taken hold that investment must continue regardless of cost or immediate performance."
Under this policy stance, the United States has been pursuing the so-called "Golden Dome Project," which connects unmanned forces and satellite networks through AI, and the recent AI craze is also an extension of the roadmap presented in the "National AI Strategy Report" led in 2019 by former Google co-founder Eric Schmidt, he explained. For this reason, he emphasized that the recent wave of AI investments should be seen not as mere technology diffusion but as building national infrastructure that underpins military and geopolitical hegemony competition. "Because issues of security and hegemony are embedded in this, U.S. companies will not easily stop injecting capital," he said.
"Can Korea endure?...Must be incorporated into the U.S. supply chain"
He expressed concern that the perception is spreading that Korea holds excessive leadership in the global supply chain. Although there is a view that Korea can "hold out" against U.S. tariff pressure and trade policies, he explained that within the broader U.S. frame, Korea is in reality closer to playing the role of supplying key hardware components than leading the AI ecosystem.
Kwon said, "Right now, memory demand is strong, so even that role alone generates sufficient profit, but if we take an excessively hard-line stance based on this, it could become disadvantageous in the mid to long term." He particularly pointed out that Micron's new fabs under construction in Idaho and New York in the United States are scheduled to begin phased operations next year and the year after, and that major Taiwanese electronics manufacturers such as Foxconn, Wistron, and Pegatron are also rapidly establishing production bases in Mexico and across North America. In other words, the pace of restructuring the supply chain into a U.S.-centered 'closed loop' is faster than expected.
He said, "Precisely because the value of Korean memory has risen, now is the golden time to go out aggressively into the market," adding, "Rather than holding out excessively, we need a strategy of quickly securing positions wherever conditions allow."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
In this same context, he interpreted semiconductor manufacturing reshoring not as a domain of cost competition but as one where strategic value takes precedence. "The trend of entrusting advanced-node semiconductor manufacturing to Asia purely because of cost competitiveness will weaken going forward," he said. "Both Taiwan and Korea could face difficulties within the 'security and sovereignty' frame." The current moment, when the AI boom has increased Korea's bargaining power, is an opportunity to be incorporated on favorable terms into the semiconductor supply chain being reorganized around the United States, he argued, and as advanced-node processes shift into the security and sovereignty frame, both Korea and Taiwan could become disadvantaged.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.