"Concerns That Single-Term System for Outside Directors Could Worsen Hiring Difficulties and Weaken Expertise"
70% of outside directors at the six major financial holding companies
Terms expire in March as authorities review "three-year single-term" system
Financial sector fears "worsening hiring difficulties over independence"
As the terms of outside directors at the four major domestic financial holding companies near expiration, these groups are facing growing concerns. This is because the financial authorities have defined outside directors as a shield for imperial-style management and are ramping up the pressure. On top of this, news that the authorities are even reviewing a plan to limit outside director terms to a single three-year term has raised fears that, contrary to the stated goal of enhancing board independence, it could paradoxically worsen hiring difficulties and weaken the board’s oversight function.
Authorities weighing shift from 6-year reappointment system to 3-year single-term system...Will outside directors be replaced en masse?
According to the financial sector on the 4th, more than 70% of the 46 outside directors at six financial holding companies — KB, Shinhan, Hana, Woori, NongHyup Financial, and BNK Financial, which has been embroiled in controversy over its chairman selection process — a total of 32 directors, are facing term expiration in March.
By group, Hana Financial has the largest number, with 8 out of 9 outside directors reaching the end of their terms, followed by Shinhan Financial with 7 out of 9, KB Financial with 5 out of 7, and Woori and NongHyup Financial with 3 out of 7 each. At BNK Financial Group as well, 6 out of 7 outside directors will see their terms expire. More than half of these directors have already been reappointed at least once. Currently, outside directors at financial holding companies serve an initial two-year term and can then be reappointed annually up to four additional times, allowing them to serve for a maximum of six years.
This practice may now be subject to a brake. According to the financial sector, the task force (TF) on improving the governance structure of financial holding companies is reportedly reviewing a plan to change the outside director term system from the current "maximum six-year reappointment system" to a "three-year single-term system." This follows persistent criticism both inside and outside the financial industry that, because reappointment is influenced by recommendation procedures in which management is involved, outside directors may be passive in monitoring and checking the incumbent management.
Concerns over worsening hiring difficulties and weaker independence...Core issue is "people, not terms"
However, within the financial sector there are concerns that introducing a single-term system for outside directors could lead to the side effect of more severe hiring difficulties. Under the Act on Corporate Governance of Financial Companies and other regulations, outside directors at financial holding companies are subject to far stricter regulations and internal controls than outside directors at holding companies in other industries. While the regulations are demanding, they also require a high level of expertise in specific areas such as macroeconomic analysis, risk management, and consumer protection. As a result, the pool of potential candidates for outside director positions at financial holding companies is limited, and talent tends to be concentrated in certain groups, such as academics.
In this situation, critics point out that if terms are further restricted to a single term, the attractiveness of serving as an outside director will diminish and the candidate pool could narrow even more. A representative of a domestic financial holding company said, "If a single-term system for outside directors is implemented, hiring difficulties are highly likely to intensify," adding, "Financial holding companies are organizations that require expertise, and if a single-term system is introduced, we will not be able to reappoint individuals once they complete their term, which will inevitably cause the pool of proven talent to shrink rapidly."
Lee Namwoo, Chairman of the Korea Corporate Governance Forum, also noted, "In general, it takes at least two to three years after a director is appointed for that person to fully understand the company’s business structure and risks, and only then does it become possible to engage in substantive discussions based on independent judgment and sufficient information," and warned, "If the term is too short, there is a high risk that the board will degenerate into a mere formality."
There are also concerns that, contrary to the stated aim of reducing collusion with inside directors, the independence of outside directors and their ability to keep management in check could actually be weakened. Another official at a financial holding company said, "If we move to a single-term system, outside directors will have to be replaced more frequently, and in that case, the overall stability and independence of the board could decline," adding, "Rather than focusing solely on the length of outside directors’ terms, we need to comprehensively examine whether they can properly fulfill their roles in monitoring management and protecting shareholders and other stakeholders."
In pursuing greater diversity on boards, there is also concern that trade secrets could inadvertently be exposed to the outside. On January 5, Financial Supervisory Service Governor Lee Chanjin pointed out that at JP Morgan and U.S.-based investment banks (IBs), directors from rival firms serve as board members and there are almost no professors. However, within the domestic financial sector, there are significant concerns that appointing outside directors who previously worked at competing financial institutions could lead to leakage of business strategies to the outside.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Some argue that, in a situation where there is an absolute shortage of "good directors" who possess both independence and expertise, simply tightening regulations without expanding the size and quality of the talent pool cannot be a real solution. Chairman Lee Namwoo said, "The essence of the problem lies not in the term length but in the people," and advised, "The government and the National Assembly should take the lead in revitalizing director education and training programs, which is the proper approach, and there is a need to reorganize systematic director education and training programs, as we had in the past."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.