Discriminatory Elements in the Special Bills for "Chungnam-Daejeon" and "Jeonnam-Gwangju" Highlighted as Major Issues
Imbalance of Authority Between "Chungnam-Daejeon" and "Jeonnam-Gwangju" Must Be Thoroughly Discussed and Amended During the Legislative Process
"If Daejeon Citizens and Chungnam Residents Are Misled, There Will Be a Clear Reckoning"

Lee Jangwoo, Mayor of Daejeon (Photo by Seokbong Mo)

Lee Jangwoo, Mayor of Daejeon (Photo by Seokbong Mo)

View original image

On the afternoon of February 2, Lee Jangwoo, Mayor of Daejeon, held a press conference in the city hall briefing room and stated, "When looking at the special bills for Chungnam-Daejeon and Jeonnam-Gwangju proposed by the Democratic Party, it has become absolutely impossible to overcome the Seoul metropolitan area-centric system, respond to the risk of local extinction, or compete with global cities." He added, "Now is the time for the President to make a bold decision to legally guarantee fiscal decentralization and local autonomy."


He continued, "When I look at this bill, I cannot help but question the commitment to local and regional decentralization," expressing serious concerns about whether there is any genuine intent to pursue true local autonomy and decentralization.


He went on to say, "I believe it is time for the President to clearly demonstrate his willingness to transfer authority and fiscal power for local decentralization," urging the President to promptly revise the bill so that his commitment to decentralization is clearly reflected in the legislation.


Mayor Lee strongly criticized the National Assembly members representing Chungnam and Daejeon.


He said, "Frankly, I do not understand how the Democratic Party could propose such discriminatory bills for Chungnam-Daejeon and Jeonnam-Gwangju on the same day," adding, "Looking at the bill submitted by the Chungnam-Daejeon lawmakers, I truly question whether these local representatives are qualified to represent this region," expressing his disappointment.


He further stated, "There is no hope left for the local National Assembly members," and reiterated that "only a decisive move by the President can be expected," once again calling for the President's decision.


He warned the government, "If Daejeon citizens and Chungnam residents are misled in this way, there will be a clear reckoning."


Mayor Lee also pointed out issues with the process of the Daejeon-Chungnam administrative integration and the special bill that has been underway.


He explained, "Daejeon Metropolitan City and Chungcheongnam-do have been pursuing integration to overcome the Seoul metropolitan area-centric system and proactively respond to the crisis of local extinction." He added, "Since the joint declaration of integration in November 2024, the research institutes of both regions, experts, and public-private consultative bodies have engaged in extensive discussions to prepare a special bill that includes matters related to fiscal, organizational, and authority transfers for decentralization and balanced development."


He continued, "This special bill was completed after thoroughly listening to residents' opinions across the 20 cities, counties, and districts of Daejeon and Chungnam, and after deliberation and approval by both regional councils. As a result, in October last year, a special bill for the establishment of Daejeon-Chungnam Special City and the creation of an economic and science capital was proposed in the National Assembly, led by Assemblyman Sung Iljong."


He pointed out, "However, following the President's remarks on Daejeon-Chungnam integration in December last year, the Democratic Party abruptly proposed a new party-line bill on January 30 for the establishment of the Chungnam-Daejeon Integrated Special City and the creation of an economic, scientific, and defense hub." He criticized, "Upon reviewing the proposed bill, the name of the special city has been changed, fiscal support is temporary, and the scope of transferred work and authority has been significantly reduced."


He reiterated his criticism, stating, "If this special bill passes the National Assembly as is, it will merely extend the current system of subordinate local decentralization, where the central government distributes authority and budgets at its discretion."


Photo by Daejeon City

Photo by Daejeon City

View original image

◆ 55 Provisions Rejected, Centered on Local Fiscal Authority and Preliminary Feasibility Study Exceptions


Securing fiscal autonomy that allows the region to independently formulate and implement policies is the most critical factor for the success of Daejeon-Chungnam Special City. The core of the original special bill was to realize a genuine local government through the transfer of national taxes to local governments.


The Democratic Party's party-line bill does not include most provisions related to local fiscal autonomy. The Prime Minister's announcement in January, which mentioned 5 trillion won per year, was not specifically stipulated, and it remains unclear whether this amount includes grants to cities, counties, and districts.


▲ Permanent transfer of corporate and value-added taxes as national taxes ▲ An additional 6% allocation of the total ordinary local grants for Daejeon and Chungnam over 10 years ▲ National support for the Science and Technology Promotion Fund and the Special Fund for Low Birthrate Response were all excluded.


Furthermore, to rapidly establish Daejeon-Chungnam Special City as an economic and science capital, central government regulations must be streamlined, but the Democratic Party's party-line bill maintains excessive central regulations.


▲ Exemption from investment review and preliminary feasibility studies for 10 years ▲ Exemption from preliminary feasibility studies for the development of railways, expressways, and advanced strategic industries ▲ Transfer of authority over development-restricted zones were all omitted.


◆ More Than Half of 136 Special Exceptions Revised to Reduce Local Autonomy


Many special provisions designed to secure a high degree of autonomy for Daejeon-Chungnam Special City are now at risk of not being realized.


Mandatory provisions expressed as "shall" have been changed to discretionary provisions as "may," weakening state obligations, and additional procedures for central government consultation or consent have actually strengthened regulations.


Additionally, matters previously determined by the special city, special mayor, or ordinances have been revised to be decided by the state, ministers, or presidential decrees, reducing local autonomy. Conversely, special provisions that would be effective only if implemented by the state have been changed so that the special city is now the responsible party, increasing the burden on the special city.


Photo by Daejeon City

Photo by Daejeon City

View original image

◆ Notably, Significant Reduction of Local Autonomy in Fiscal and Science-Economy Provisions


The special bill proposed in October last year mandated national support for all administrative integration costs and specified the reasons for fiscal support in detail, but the Democratic Party's party-line bill changed national support to a discretionary provision and removed specific reasons.


In the case of transferring the work of special local administrative agencies, which was included in the Prime Minister's announcement in January, the special bill proposed in October last year made it mandatory, but the Democratic Party's party-line bill changed it to a discretionary provision.


For the designation and operation of metropolitan living zones, introduced to handle regional work within the special city, the Democratic Party's party-line bill excluded provisions for national fiscal support.


National administrative and fiscal support, as well as regulatory relaxation for demonstration projects required for the science-oriented city development plan, were also reduced from mandatory to discretionary provisions in the Democratic Party's party-line bill.


The special bill proposed in October last year required the state to provide administrative and fiscal support to foster industries such as semiconductors, bio, defense, aerospace, and displays as advanced strategic industries for the special city, but the Democratic Party's party-line bill changed this to a discretionary provision.


In addition, the obligation for the state to provide additional grants to companies relocating to the special city was changed to a discretionary provision in the Democratic Party's party-line bill, and tax reductions for development projects were limited to local taxes, excluding national taxes.


◆ Weakening of Local Autonomy in Transportation, Environment, and Balanced Regional Development


The special exception to increase the national treasury support ratio for metropolitan transportation facilities, essential for creating Daejeon-Chungnam as a unified economic and living zone, was excluded from the Democratic Party's party-line bill, and national support for public transportation operating losses was changed from mandatory to discretionary.


The special bill proposed in October last year allowed for the omission of consultation with the Ministry of Health and Welfare when introducing new social security systems, but the Democratic Party's party-line bill only allows for a request to simplify the consultation process.


Additionally, regarding changes to land use zones and authority over building coverage and floor area ratios in station areas, the special bill proposed in October last year assigned these powers to the special mayor, but the Democratic Party's party-line bill assigned them by presidential decree, resulting in no actual transfer of authority.


◆ Resolving Central-Local Imbalances in Authority and Finance Is Essential to Persuade Residents


Although the Daejeon-Chungnam integration is intended as the starting point for a national overhaul looking ahead to the next 100 years for Korea and Daejeon-Chungnam, if the integration proceeds mainly based on the Democratic Party's party-line bill, it is highly likely to end up as a mere physical merger.


This would make it difficult to gain residents' consent for the integration and could lead to serious problems arising from community division.


In particular, when compared to the "Special Act on the Establishment of Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City" proposed on the same day as the Daejeon-Chungnam bill under the Democratic Party's party line, the problems become even more pronounced.


For example, in the case of transferring the work of special local administrative agencies, the Jeonnam-Gwangju bill stipulates this as a mandatory provision, while the Daejeon-Chungnam bill makes it discretionary. For national support for administrative integration costs, Jeonnam-Gwangju is mandatory, while Daejeon-Chungnam is discretionary.


Furthermore, in the case of transferring authority over the management of development-restricted zones, Jeonnam-Gwangju is included, but Daejeon-Chungnam is not.


The installation of mixed-use lanes for trams and automobiles is included in Jeonnam-Gwangju, but not in Daejeon-Chungnam.


For the authority to omit consultation when introducing new social security systems, Jeonnam-Gwangju is included, but Daejeon-Chungnam only allows for a request to simplify the process.


The imbalance in authority between Jeonnam-Gwangju and Daejeon-Chungnam must be thoroughly discussed and revised during the legislative process in the National Assembly.



Mayor Lee emphasized, "The National Assembly should boldly relinquish central fiscal and regulatory authority and clearly stipulate this in the special law, reflecting the President's strong commitment to local autonomy and decentralization." He added, "I hope that the finalized Daejeon-Chungnam special bill (proposed by Assemblyman Sung Iljong), which was completed with only the future of the region in mind and without regard to political gains or losses, will not be undermined."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing