Court Rules "Reprimand Is Invalid"
Ministry of Education’s Belated Audit Halted Disciplinary Action

Court.

Court.

View original image

Even if a university’s articles of association partially conflict with the higher law, the Private School Act, a court has ruled that a university president cannot be disciplined solely for carrying out work in accordance with the procedures set by those articles. In particular, the court found it procedurally unlawful for the university to repeatedly convene a disciplinary committee and enforce disciplinary action simply because the Ministry of Education demanded corrective measures.


On February 2, according to the legal community, the 13th Civil Division of the Gwangju District Court (Presiding Judge Jung Youngho) ruled in favor of Kim Jeongsu, President of Seoyoung University, in a lawsuit filed against the Seogang Academy Foundation to confirm the invalidity of disciplinary action. The court ordered, “It is confirmed that the reprimand imposed by the defendant (the foundation) on the plaintiff (President Kim) is invalid.”


This lawsuit stemmed from an issue regarding the payment of honorary retirement allowances for faculty members.


In June 2020, Seogang Academy Foundation revised its articles of association to ease the requirement for faculty honorary retirement allowances, reducing the required years of service from “20 years or more” to “15 years or more,” and reported this change to the Ministry of Education. At the time, the Ministry of Education did not issue any specific corrective order regarding the change.


In June 2022, President Kim, following the revised articles, approved the honorary retirement of Professor A, who had 18 years of service, through a board resolution and paid the allowance.


However, during a subsequent audit, the Ministry of Education pointed out that “the Private School Act stipulates honorary retirement allowances are to be paid only after 20 years of service,” identified this as a violation of the law, and demanded disciplinary action against President Kim.


In response, the university convened a faculty disciplinary committee, but both the first and second reviews concluded, “The Ministry of Education did not raise any issue with the change to the articles, and the president simply followed the articles,” and decided not to impose any disciplinary action.


Nevertheless, after repeated demands for corrective action from the Ministry of Education, the university convened a third disciplinary committee and ultimately issued a reprimand, a minor disciplinary action, to President Kim. President Kim filed a lawsuit in response.


The court stated, “Even if the articles of association partially violate the Private School Act, President Kim’s actions were merely the performance of his duties in accordance with the revised articles. It cannot be concluded that he intentionally violated the Private School Act, and thus there are no grounds for disciplinary action.”


The court also pointed out procedural issues.



The court ruled, “Even though it was already decided twice not to impose disciplinary action, there is no legal basis for the foundation to demand a third review solely at the request of the Ministry of Education. This disciplinary action constitutes an abuse and overreach of discretionary power by the disciplinary authority and is therefore invalid.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing