Token Penalties Lead to "Rational Security Neglect"
Data Breaches Are Not Disasters, But Failures of Law and Policy

[THE VIEW] Why They Are Not Afraid of the Law View original image

In the era of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, data is often called the "crude oil of the 21st century." Yet in South Korea, this precious resource is gushing out of leaky pipes. From the recent controversy over Coupang's massive customer data leak to the incident in which telecom companies had hundreds of thousands of customers' data stolen, our society's complacency about digital security has passed the danger threshold. Nevertheless, companies try to gloss over the situation with a single written apology. Why do such backward incidents keep recurring?


We often try to dismiss hacking or data breaches as unavoidable disasters or mere technical mistakes. However, from a law-and-economics perspective, as articulated by Gary Becker, personal data leaks in Korea are the product of a cold-blooded "economic calculation." Becker argued that crime and legal violations are determined by a functional relationship between benefits and costs. From a corporate standpoint, a robust security system is an expense that requires enormous capital. In contrast, the cost of a data breach is merely the fine at a slap-on-the-wrist level multiplied by the probability of getting caught.


Take Coupang and the telecom companies. They are, in effect, "fintech (finance + technology) companies" that handle not only retail and telecommunications, but also easy payment services and financial data. Yet the penalties they face for violating the Personal Information Protection Act amount to little more than pocket change compared to their revenue. The calculation made by management is straightforward. It is far cheaper to pay fines and legal fees when an incident occurs than to spend tens of billions of won building a security system. In other words, weak security at Korean companies is not a mistake; it is a "rational management decision" aimed at maximizing profit.


Whenever this kind of moral hazard is pointed out, the business community protests that "excessive punishment will stifle data utilization and innovation." But this is sophistry that ignores how trust functions in markets. In today's markets, where finance and IT are fused, data security is synonymous with creditworthiness. Can a company that fails to protect customer information really become a key player in the Fourth Industrial Revolution? In fact, it is precisely this neglect of security risks that can fuel the chronic "Korea discount" plaguing Korean capital markets.


Global investors distrust the weak governance of Korean companies. Foreign investors are well aware that, because there is no sense of crisis that a breach could bring down the company, firms are unwilling to spend money on internal control systems such as security. It is unrealistic to expect global capital to award high valuations to companies that loudly champion ESG (environment, social, and governance) management, yet treat the most basic social responsibility (S) of managing customer data as something to be weighed against cost efficiency.


Lenient penalties also hinder the "financialization of security technology" and its development. If a company had to pay damages so large that a single data breach could drive it into bankruptcy, firms would stake their survival on adopting the best possible security technologies. Capital would naturally flow into the security industry, spurring technological innovation. But under the current system, where "you just pay a fine even if you get hacked," no company is willing to pay top dollar for security. In the end, the lax legal framework erodes corporate credibility and creates a vicious cycle that blocks the growth of related industries.


Look at advanced economies such as the United States and countries in Europe. Through punitive damages and strong personal data protection regulations such as the GDPR, they impose astronomical liability on companies that leak customer information. They provide a clear economic incentive: "Investing in security is far cheaper than paying for the aftermath of an incident." This is the secret behind why global big tech companies possess competitive security technologies and are highly valued in financial markets.


It is time for us to forcibly change the corporate calculator as well. We need to dramatically lower the threshold for class actions and introduce punitive damages, instilling a very real fear that a single data breach could shake a company's very existence. Only then will companies finally recognize security not as a "cost" but as an "investment for survival."


There is no future for a data economy or financial innovation in a country where personal information is traded for next to nothing. It is time to enshrine in law the harsh principle that companies that cannot protect consumer data do not even deserve to talk about innovation.



Professor Sungkyu Park, Willamette University (U.S.)


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing