Lee Raises 'Sugar Levy' Again... A Healthy Tax or a Signal for Tax Hikes? View original image

President Lee Jaemyung has repeatedly expressed his intention to initiate public debate on the introduction of a sugar levy, reigniting related controversy. In order to avoid framing the measure as a tax increase, the administration has chosen to impose a levy rather than create a new tax category. However, some argue that there will still be significant tax resistance, as the measure could lead to higher prices and is seen as targeting a specific industry.


On February 1, President Lee wrote on his social media account X (formerly Twitter), "I look forward to an in-depth and rational debate on whether to introduce a sugar levy." This marked his renewed commitment to the sugar tax following his initial mention of it on January 28. In response to criticism from the opposition that the measure effectively constitutes a tax increase, he proposed a debate, stating, "This is not a tax, but a way to reduce the burden of national health insurance premiums." The presidential office added, "We plan to gather opinions from various sectors and review measures to address public health issues caused by sugar consumption, as well as ways to reinvest the proceeds to strengthen regional and public healthcare."


Lee Raises 'Sugar Levy' Again... A Healthy Tax or a Signal for Tax Hikes? View original image

Levy Instead of New Tax Category... Aiming to Reduce Tax Resistance

The president’s repeated emphasis that this is a levy, not a tax, is interpreted as an attempt to secure additional funding while avoiding the controversy over tax increases. Levies, which are quasi-tax in nature, are limited to serving the public interest. A representative example is the National Health Promotion Levy imposed on tobacco, which poses a risk of causing lung cancer. The National Health Promotion Levy of 841 won per pack of cigarettes can only be used for smoking cessation and public health projects. The rationale for introducing a sugar levy is similar. As excessive sugar consumption leads to an increase in obesity and chronic diseases such as hypertension and diabetes, which in turn increases the financial burden on the national health insurance system, the idea is to reflect these social costs in sugar prices to reduce sugar consumption.


However, unlike tobacco, sugar is a key raw material that is widely used not only in beverages but also in processed foods such as bread and snacks, as well as in the food service industry, potentially driving up overall food prices. Although the levy would be imposed on manufacturers or importers and distributors rather than consumers, if product prices rise by the same amount as the health promotion levy, consumer food prices will inevitably increase. Given the prolonged period of high inflation in recent years, experts point out that this will inevitably stimulate perceived inflation. Ahn Changnam, a professor of tax accounting at Kangnam University, stated, "Sugar has low price elasticity of demand, so unless consumption drops significantly, companies are likely to pass the entire tax burden onto the sales price, which means consumers will ultimately bear the cost."


Denmark introduced a "fat tax" in October 2012, imposing a levy of 16 kroner per kilogram of saturated fat on all foods containing fat, such as butter and meat. However, as production costs for companies rose and consumer prices surged, cross-border shopping increased, leading to unintended side effects. As a result, Denmark announced the repeal of the tax after just one year. In Korea, a similar amendment to the National Health Promotion Act was proposed by lawmakers in 2021, but it was scrapped due to concerns about the burden on low-income households. At the time, a National Assembly review report warned, "If a levy is imposed on sugar, which is a basic necessity, the cost will inevitably be passed on to consumers." The World Health Organization (WHO) also pointed out in its 2022 "Taxation Policy Manual for Promoting Healthy Diets through Sugar-Sweetened Beverages" that "tax increases, which lead to higher prices, have a greater impact on vulnerable groups such as young people and low-income households."


The Effectiveness of Corrective Taxation Must Be Examined First

The political community has begun reviewing legislative options. Jeong Taeho, a lawmaker from the Democratic Party of Korea and the ruling party’s secretary of the National Assembly’s Strategy and Finance Committee, plans to hold a "National Assembly Forum on the Sugar Overuse Levy" on February 12 to discuss ways to introduce the sugar levy. Previously, on January 29, Kim Sunmin, a lawmaker from the National Innovation Party, sponsored an amendment to the National Health Promotion Act that would impose a levy of 225 to 300 won per liter on sugar-sweetened beverages.



Experts argue that, rather than pushing forward with legislation, there should first be a social consensus on the effectiveness and purpose of introducing a new levy. Kim Woochul, a professor of tax accounting at University of Seoul, stated, "Although the government has chosen to call it a levy to reduce tax resistance, in practice, levies are indirect taxes and have the same economic effect as taxes." He added, "Before expanding tax revenues, it is necessary to examine the overall effectiveness of corrective taxes such as fuel and liquor taxes, which should serve a more corrective function than the sugar tax, and to prioritize the rationalization of excessive tax expenditures."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing