"A Highway Without Speed Enforcement"
Consumers Cannot Verify, Trust Is Not Earned

[Insight & Opinion] The 'GMO Labeling System' That Cannot Be Technically Verified View original image

Starting December 31, the "GMO Full Labeling System" will be implemented. This is not the introduction of a new system, but rather an expansion of the scope of the "GMO Labeling System" that has already been in place since 2001.


Consumer advocacy groups emphasizing the "right to know," as well as farmers cultivating domestic soybeans and corn, have welcomed this change. In contrast, both consumers and the food industry find themselves in a difficult position. The prices of soybean oil and starch syrup are expected to rise, and securing raw materials has become a concern. This does not necessarily mean that consumers or the environment will become safer or cleaner.


There are also concerns about market confusion after the full labeling system is implemented. This is because it is technically impossible to determine whether GMO ingredients have been used in starch syrup or soybean oil from which genetically modified DNA and proteins have been removed. Under the GMO Full Labeling System, even the "country of origin labeling system," which relies on trained inspectors to visually identify distinguishing features, cannot be applied to actual products. Furthermore, it is not feasible to apply the European Union's "GMO Production Traceability System" to imported corn and soybeans grown in other countries.


Ultimately, consumers will have no choice but to unconditionally trust unilateral GMO labeling by producers. It is unrealistic to expect consumers to trust a GMO full labeling system that they cannot verify in practice. If not handled properly, an unmanageable full labeling system could become a bad law that only amplifies social distrust.


The Ministry of Food and Drug Safety, which is in charge of managing the GMO Full Labeling System, is taking a passive approach. The ministry relies on the "Identity Preservation Certificate," which importers provide to claim that GMOs have been properly separated and handled during the import process. The ministry's passive stance is akin to trusting drivers' pledges not to speed on highways and therefore not installing speed enforcement equipment. In reality, newly opened highways inevitably become playgrounds for reckless drivers before speed enforcement equipment is installed. The argument that the food market will be different is unconvincing.


Introducing a grace period for the implementation of the full labeling system is also awkward. For example, soy sauce, which mostly uses domestic non-GMO ingredients, will be subject to immediate implementation starting next year, while for starch syrup and soybean oil, the length of the grace period will vary depending on the proportion of imported GMO ingredients used. However, producers have no clear justification for needing a grace period. There is no need to develop new technologies or products, nor is it necessary to establish contract farming for imported corn and soybeans.


Active efforts are needed to overcome the social aversion to GMOs. The outdated notion that genetic modification "infringes on the realm of God" must be firmly discarded. Genetic modification is not a new concept. "Breeding," which uses hybridization to improve varieties, is also a form of genetic modification technology. It is unreasonable and embarrassing to accept genetic modification through breeding but reject genetic modification through advanced biotechnology such as "reverse transcription" or "gene editing."


Concerns about the potential risks of GMOs to human health and the environment are also unfounded. The possibility of harm from GMOs is scientifically proven to be no different from that of agricultural, fishery, and livestock products produced through traditional breeding. Even the Royal Society in the United Kingdom, which has led the opposition to GMOs, acknowledges their safety. For a country that imports half of its food and whose grain self-sufficiency rate is less than 20%, the argument that we must reject GMOs to protect domestic agricultural products is so unreasonable that even a cow would laugh.



Lee Deokhwan, Professor Emeritus at Sogang University, Chemistry and Science Communication


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing