Second Roundtable Between Ministry of SMEs and Homeplus Store Owners
Government Measures Rendered Ineffective by Loan Limits
Additional Steps Needed, Such as Easing Guarantee Requirements

[Reporter’s Notebook] Government Says Homeplus Closures Are Not a 'Disaster' View original image

"The government promised financial support, raising expectations, but in reality, there are far more people who couldn't get loans than those who did."


The second roundtable meeting between the Ministry of SMEs and Startups and Homeplus store owners, held on January 29, turned into a heated session of complaints. The event was organized to check the response on the ground after the government, as promised during the first roundtable, expanded the eligibility for emergency management stabilization funds for small business owners to all Homeplus stores and removed requirements related to relocation and restarting businesses.


The reactions of the store owners gathered at the meeting were much colder than expected. Contrary to the government's explanation, most on site said it was difficult to feel the effects of these support measures.


The issue was with existing loans taken out reluctantly due to the domestic economic downturn and the rise in raw material prices. The emergency management stabilization fund for small business owners has a maximum limit of 70 million won, but the majority of store owners had already maxed out their limit with loans taken before the closure of their Homeplus branches, or if they had any capacity left, the available loan amount was too small—rendering the government’s measures practically useless.


This disconnect stemmed from the difference in perception between the government and small business owners regarding financial support. The emergency management stabilization fund is divided into two main types: "temporary management difficulties" and "disaster damage." For the former, loan availability depends on the individual’s credit limit, but for disaster damage, anyone facing hardship can receive support regardless of their loan limit.


The government explained that, since this situation did not fall under disasters specified by the Framework Act on the Management of Disasters and Safety—such as typhoons, floods, or heavy rain—the current support had to be classified as assistance for temporary management difficulties. However, for store owners facing the unique crisis of the Homeplus situation, who had hoped for a type of disaster relief that anyone could receive, the government's measures were inevitably disappointing. As one store owner put it, "The only difference is the lower interest rate—how is this any different from previous loans?"—a sentiment that encapsulates the current mood.


As the government explained, it is not easy to make exceptions to policy criteria for specific situations. This could also raise issues of fairness. Nevertheless, it is hardly desirable that the majority of small business owners at Homeplus stores are unable to benefit from government measures due to rigid eligibility requirements. One store owner who attended the roundtable said that he had invested 70 million won of general management stabilization funds into his store, but due to the Homeplus crisis, he could not recover any of it and was even blocked from receiving further policy funds. In effect, the damage from the Homeplus situation has created a vicious cycle, preventing additional support.



As of now, the total number of stores that have closed or are scheduled to close due to the Homeplus crisis has increased to 17. The business conditions for store owners are expected to worsen further. Even if special disaster relief-type support is difficult, as store owners hope, additional measures such as easing guarantee requirements or adjusting loan limits are absolutely necessary. There is a reason this is being called the "Homeplus incident." The situation cannot be resolved with an attitude focused only on the legal definition of "disaster."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing