Maximizing Returns Through "Economies of Scale"
Unlocking Funds Tied to Principal Guarantees

[K-Women Talk] Misconceptions and Truths About the Fund-Type Retirement Pension System View original image

The stock market is soaring. The KOSPI has already surpassed the 5,000 mark at the beginning of the year, ushering in an era we have never experienced before, and the upward trend remains strong. Meanwhile, as stock investment returns rise, the low yield of retirement pensions is once again under scrutiny.


There are ongoing concerns that the five-year average annual return of retirement pensions, which are a core source of retirement income for employees, stands at only 2.86%, falling short of the inflation rate. A closer look at the returns reveals that this is just an average; for DC plans, the top-performing 1% achieved a return of 22.7%. Since these figures are based on 2024, returns would likely have risen even further based on the more active stock market in 2025. Returns vary depending on the products chosen. Principal-guaranteed products offer an average return in the 3% range, while performance-based products average around 9%, showing a significant gap. However, since 75% of Korea’s retirement pension reserves are invested in principal-guaranteed products, overall returns inevitably remain low.


Recently, the introduction of the “fund-type retirement pension system” has been the focus of discussions as an alternative to boost retirement pension yields. However, there appear to be many misunderstandings about the adoption of this fund-type system. I even heard a well-known economics YouTuber describe the fund-type retirement pension system as the creation of a single, massive Retirement Pension Headquarters that collects and manages all retirement pensions together, similar to the National Pension Service. This is a significant misconception. I believe the legislative and policy authorities, as well as retirement pension experts, also share responsibility for such misunderstandings.


Let’s first review the definition of the fund-type retirement pension system. Currently, the standard is the “contract-type retirement pension system,” in which a company entrusts the management of its retirement pension to a financial institution such as a bank, insurance company, or securities firm through a one-on-one contract.


The fund-type retirement pension system, by contrast, establishes a separate fund corporation that pools and manages the retirement pensions of employees from multiple companies, not just a single firm. Unlike the contract-type system, where an individual employee or company decides how to manage their pension assets, the fund-type system entrusts management entirely to the fund corporation, which is staffed by retirement pension experts. By pooling the retirement pensions of employees from several companies and benefiting from economies of scale, it is highly likely that returns will improve. Whether a company adopts the contract-type or the fund-type system is purely a matter of choice. Currently, the Small and Medium-Sized Enterprise (SME) Retirement Pension Fund run by the Korea Workers’ Compensation and Welfare Service, which is open only to employees of workplaces with 30 or fewer employees, operates under the fund-type system. The choice between contract-type and fund-type is made jointly by employees and employers. However, apart from workplaces with 30 or fewer employees, the fund-type system is not legally recognized at present. The main intent of current discussions is to introduce the fund-type system to expand the range of choices.


Retirement pensions are, at their core, “mandatory private pensions.” Unlike the National Pension, which is a public pension, the government may design the framework but cannot arbitrarily draw from the funds for purposes such as defending the exchange rate or stabilizing stock prices. The government also cannot guarantee payments. Furthermore, unlike the National Pension, which combines partial funding and pay-as-you-go elements, retirement pensions are paid out solely based on the amount an individual has contributed, plus investment returns. Therefore, I believe it is important to broaden the range of institutional options so that labor and management, as the main stakeholders of retirement pensions, can ensure robust post-retirement income based on their own judgment and responsibility.



Kim Kyung-Seon, Chairperson of the Korea Retirement Pension Development Institute and former Vice Minister of Gender Equality and Family


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing