Acquittal Verdicts of Lower Courts Overturned

The Supreme Court has overturned a lower court's acquittal of an individual wearing an electronic ankle monitor who violated nighttime curfew conditions by returning home 10 minutes late, and has remanded the case to a lower court for a guilty verdict.

Reference image. Yonhap News Agency

Reference image. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on February 2, the Supreme Court's Second Division (Presiding Justice Park Youngjae) overturned the lower court's acquittal of Mr. A, who had been indicted for violating the Act on the Attachment of Electronic Devices, and sent the case back to the Jeju District Court. Previously, both the first and second instance courts had found Mr. A not guilty of violating the curfew, but imposed a fine of 1 million won for refusing a breathalyzer test.


In February 2011, Mr. A was sentenced to 10 years in prison and 15 years of electronic monitoring for sexual violence crimes, including the rape of a minor. In addition, in November 2022, the Jeju District Court imposed an additional special condition requiring him to refrain from leaving his residence between 00:00 and 06:00 every day.


However, on the night of January 17, 2023, Mr. A was drinking at a karaoke bar in Jeju City and returned home late, violating the curfew for about 10 minutes from 00:00 to 00:10 the next day. It was found that Mr. A had contacted the probation office in advance, stating, "I can't get a taxi, so I'm walking home and will be about 10 minutes late."


The first and second instance courts ruled, "It is difficult to consider a single instance of returning home 10 minutes late as a violation of the conditions," and acquitted him.

Supreme Court: "Even a 10-Minute Late Return by Sex Offender with Electronic Anklet Violates Compliance Requirements" View original image

However, the Supreme Court's judgment differed. The Supreme Court stated, "Considering the legislative intent of the Act on the Attachment of Electronic Devices and the wording of the curfew condition, it means that, in principle, the individual must remain at their residence during the specified period, such as at night, throughout the duration of the electronic monitoring."


The court further pointed out, "Returning home 10 minutes late after drinking at a karaoke bar cannot be considered a justifiable reason, and the defendant's intent to violate the conditions is also recognized."



As the Supreme Court found a legal error in the lower court's acquittal and ordered a retrial, Mr. A is now expected to be found guilty of violating the curfew condition.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing