Contradictions Undermining the Essence of Finance:
Investor Responsibility in Investment Losses
Concerns Over Abuse of Supervisory Authority:
Administrative Trust Must Not Be Eroded

[Reporter’s Notebook] FSS’s ‘ELS Fine Standard’ Ignores Court Ruling View original image

The Financial Supervisory Service’s (FSS) review of penalties regarding equity-linked securities (ELS) tied to the Hong Kong H-Index (Hang Seng China Enterprises Index, HSCEI) has now entered a third round. The FSS, which previously signaled an unprecedented fine of 2 trillion won for incomplete sales by financial institutions, maintained its hardline stance during the second disciplinary review. However, as recent court rulings have emphasized the principle of investor responsibility, criticism is mounting that the FSS’s logic for imposing penalties is increasingly disconnected from market norms.



The most concerning aspect is that this disciplinary action could set a dangerous precedent by undermining the fundamental principle of “self-responsibility” in financial markets. In a capitalist market, pursuing high returns inherently means that investors must bear the associated risks themselves. Of course, if there has been clear deception by banks, it should be strictly punished. However, pushing forward with administrative penalties while disregarding the objective standards presented by the judiciary risks being labeled an “abuse of supervisory authority.” Punitive measures lacking a solid legal basis will ultimately only shrink banks’ wealth management (WM) businesses and result in financial consumers losing access to diverse investment opportunities.


Even regarding the core issue of whether there was a “failure to fulfill the duty of explanation,” the FSS has remained unwavering. On January 16, the Seoul Central District Court dismissed a damages claim brought by an individual investor, stating that “predicting gains or losses based on future index fluctuations is the investor’s own responsibility.” The court also clarified that the “failure to present the results of a 20-year return simulation,” which the FSS had cited as a key basis for penalties, is not a standard that should be applied to banks.


Nonetheless, the FSS merely reiterated its existing arguments during the second disciplinary review. This appears to reflect an unwillingness to acknowledge that its previous actions—pressuring banks using self-compensation guidelines—were misguided. When the supervisory authority disregards judicial decisions and proceeds with predetermined conclusions, it only erodes trust in regulatory administration. This has left the financial sector largely perplexed. A senior official in the financial industry familiar with the penalty review process commented, “It’s hard to pinpoint the FSS’s exact position, but there didn’t seem to be any significant difference in the content between the first and second disciplinary reviews.”


The third disciplinary review, scheduled for February 12, will be the FSS’s last opportunity to demonstrate “dignity as a supervisory authority.” The 2 trillion won fine is a serious matter that could even threaten the soundness of banks. It is imperative for the FSS to humbly accept the court’s judgment and adjust the level of penalties to be more in line with reality.



Regulatory administration must be grounded in law and principle, not emotions or public opinion. If the FSS continues to ignore the judiciary’s decisions and act unilaterally, South Korea’s financial market will inevitably drift away from “global standards.” The upcoming third disciplinary review should be an occasion for the FSS to soberly reflect on “who these penalties are truly for.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing