"Not Simply Exceeding the Scope of a Medical Technician's Duties"
"Constitutes Unlicensed Medical Practice"

The article is unrelated to the main content.

The article is unrelated to the main content.

View original image

The court has ruled that the Ministry of Health and Welfare’s decision to suspend a dentist’s license for three months for instructing a dental hygienist to perform blood collection was lawful. The dentist argued that the act merely exceeded the scope of work permitted for dental hygienists and that a 15-day suspension would be appropriate. However, the court determined that this constituted a clear case of unlicensed medical practice, warranting a three-month suspension.


According to the legal community on February 2, the Seoul Administrative Court’s Division 5 for Administrative Cases (Presiding Judge Lee Jeongwon) ruled against the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by dentist A against the Minister of Health and Welfare, seeking to overturn the suspension of his dental license.


Dr. A, while working at a dental clinic in Seongbuk-gu, Seoul, was indicted for instructing a dental hygienist-who is not a licensed medical professional-to perform blood collection for autologous blood therapy during implant procedures. This act was carried out on approximately 570 patients, and Dr. A was fined 10 million won for violating the Medical Service Act.


Subsequently, the Ministry of Health and Welfare imposed a three-month suspension of Dr. A’s dental license, citing that he had enabled a non-medical professional to perform a medical procedure, in violation of the Medical Service Act. Dr. A argued that he simply misunderstood the scope of work permitted for dental hygienists and claimed that the violation should only warrant a 15-day suspension, leading him to file a lawsuit.


However, the court did not accept this argument. The court found that blood collection is a medical procedure requiring professional medical knowledge, and that even if a medical technician performs it outside the scope of their license-even under a doctor’s instruction-it still constitutes unlicensed medical practice. The court also pointed out that, if the plaintiff’s argument were accepted, the penalties for instructing a medical technician to perform blood collection would be much lighter than those for instructing a layperson, which would result in an unreasonable disparity in disciplinary measures.


The court stated, “It is unreasonable to interpret Article 66, Paragraph 1, Subparagraph 6 of the Medical Service Act as including cases where a medical technician is instructed to perform a medical procedure that must be performed directly by a medical professional.”



The court further emphasized, “‘Causing a medical technician to exceed the scope of their work’ refers to cases such as having a medical technician prepare medical records that must be completed directly by a medical professional. In other words, it means instructing a medical technician to perform tasks outside their scope of work that must be performed directly by a medical professional, aside from medical procedures.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing