LucentBlock Raises Objections After SFC Selection and Elimination
Agenda Postponed Twice... Pressure Mounts Ahead of First STO Approval
"Missing the Golden Window"?Industry Concerns Grow Amid Inevitable Debates Over Fairness and Political Pressu

After the institutionalization of Security Token Offerings (STO), the financial authorities are facing prolonged deliberations over the licensing of the over-the-counter (OTC) exchange that will handle fractional investment distribution. Following LucentBlock’s challenge to the process-despite being effectively eliminated-and even direct mention of the issue by President Lee Jaemyung, the Financial Services Commission (FSC), which is set to hold its final regular meeting, has twice postponed putting the agenda up for discussion, highlighting the burden it faces. Analysts say the situation has reached a point where, due to the symbolic significance of being the “first STO institutionalization license,” combined with allegations of technology theft and political pressure, any decision is likely to trigger controversy.


"Damned If They Do, Damned If They Don't: FSC Faces Dilemma Over Fractional Investment Exchange Licensing" View original image
FSC’s Prolonged Deliberations... Considering Return to Subcommittee-Why?

According to the financial investment industry on February 2, the “preliminary approval agenda for the STO OTC exchange,” which was originally expected to be tabled at the FSC’s regular meeting on January 14, is now projected to be discussed no sooner than February 11. Although the agenda item passed the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC), a subcommittee of the FSC, on January 7, it was not tabled at the subsequent FSC regular meetings on January 14 and 28, ultimately pushing the matter into the following month. Given that passing the SFC is generally considered the biggest hurdle in the approval process, this is a highly unusual situation.


Currently, the FSC is also considering the option of returning the agenda to the subcommittee stage for further review. Since the FSC’s regular meeting, which follows the SFC, is typically a formal final approval process, this would essentially mean reverting the review procedure. An FSC official stated, “We are re-examining the issues that have been raised.” Previously, the SFC reportedly selected the “KDX Consortium” led by the Korea Exchange (KRX) and the “NXT Consortium” led by Nextrade.


"Damned If They Do, Damned If They Don't: FSC Faces Dilemma Over Fractional Investment Exchange Licensing" View original image

This shift in atmosphere appears to have been driven not only by LucentBlock’s allegations of unfairness and technology theft, but also by President Lee Jaemyung’s unusual mention of the individual licensing issue at a recent Cabinet meeting, asking, “What have you decided regarding the approval of fractional investment?” Since President Lee directly emphasized the importance of rational standards and sufficient explanation to ensure that the losing side does not feel wronged, the authorities have no choice but to revisit the matter, even if a decision has already been made.


Additionally, the Ministry of SMEs and Startups is raising issues regarding the need to improve the regulatory sandbox system. The core criticism is that, contrary to the original intent of promoting institutionalization through pilot projects, opportunities are in practice being concentrated among large companies with capital and scale. As a startup, LucentBlock has operated an STO distribution service for seven years through the regulatory sandbox, but failed to pass the latest SFC review. Adding to the controversy, the Fair Trade Commission has stated that it was not consulted in advance regarding the preliminary approval, sparking a “passing controversy.” As a result, political and public attention on the issue has intensified.


"Damned If They Do, Damned If They Don't: FSC Faces Dilemma Over Fractional Investment Exchange Licensing" View original image
Conditional Approval vs. Upholding SFC Decision... Controversy Inevitable Either Way

The key issue is whether the financial authorities, who had previously signaled preliminary approval for two consortia, will now grant conditional approval to the Soyo Consortium led by LucentBlock, in addition to the KDX and NXT consortia. If LucentBlock is approved, it would amount to the authorities admitting that the previous SFC decision lacked sufficient procedural and formal legitimacy. This could reignite debates over political pressure from both the political sphere and the market. Some point out that the entire approval process being halted and the market shaken due to a single company’s public objection could itself become another fairness controversy.


Conversely, if LucentBlock is ultimately eliminated, the structural limitations of the regulatory sandbox-namely, that institutionalization of STOs inevitably favors large, well-capitalized firms-will once again come under scrutiny. In this case, calls for system reform are likely to grow even louder. In the end, regardless of which of the three consortia is ultimately selected, controversy is unlikely to subside easily.


Industry insiders are particularly concerned that the prolonged confusion over the licensing of the STO OTC exchange is already delaying the overall STO institutionalization timeline. The amendment to the Capital Markets Act Enforcement Decree to allow for the introduction of the STO OTC exchange passed in September last year, and the later the selection of operators is delayed, the later the institutionalization will be established. Some in the industry, who have waited years for institutionalization, warn that “missing the golden window for building the STO distribution infrastructure could undermine market trust itself.”


"Damned If They Do, Damned If They Don't: FSC Faces Dilemma Over Fractional Investment Exchange Licensing" View original image

Some observers suggest that the technology theft allegations raised by LucentBlock could escalate into legal disputes. LucentBlock claims that NTX signed a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) under the pretext of investment review, received confidential materials, and then used them in the competing approval process. Since technology theft from startups is a highly sensitive issue for the government, if these claims are proven true, it could have significant repercussions. Conversely, NTX acknowledges receiving materials from LucentBlock but counters that there was nothing confidential in the information provided.



An industry official commented, “All issues-from the fairness of the approval process to allegations of technology theft and political pressure-are intertwined. The FSC will be criticized for ‘stalling’ if it delays the decision, but any decision it makes will inevitably be controversial.” The official added, “How the first step is taken will determine the future direction of the STO market.” In a related development, FSC Vice Chairman Lee Eogweon avoided giving a direct answer to a question at last week’s regular briefing about the possibility of expanding OTC exchange approvals to three companies, stating, “(After the decision) we will explain the results fairly and transparently.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing