Constitutional Court Rules 3% Threshold for Proportional Representation Unconstitutional View original image

The Constitutional Court has ruled that the provision of the Public Official Election Act, which stipulates that political parties with less than 3% of the proportional representation vote cannot obtain proportional representation seats, is unconstitutional.


On January 29, the Constitutional Court, in a constitutional complaint filed by minor parties, unincorporated associations, and eligible voters regarding Article 189, Paragraph 1, Subparagraph 1 of the Public Official Election Act, ruled by a 7-to-2 majority that the provision is unconstitutional. Article 189, Paragraph 1, Subparagraph 1 of the Act requires that a party must receive at least 3% of the total valid votes nationwide to qualify for proportional representation seats.


The petitioners, who registered as proportional representation candidates for minor parties in the 21st and 22nd general elections but failed to obtain proportional representation seats due to not reaching the 3% threshold, filed a constitutional complaint in 2020, arguing that the provision violates their right to equality.


In addition, the Court also ruled unconstitutional the related provision in Subparagraph 2 of the same paragraph, which states that proportional representation seats are allocated to parties that win at least five constituency seats in the National Assembly election. The Court explained that if only the 3% vote threshold were declared unconstitutional, the requirements for proportional representation would actually become stricter than before.


The Constitutional Court stated, "The threshold provision has some institutional utility in cases where the proliferation of minor parties causes serious harm, so the purpose of the system itself cannot be deemed unreasonable." However, it also noted, "By assigning different values to votes, it increases wasted votes and undermines proportionality in elections, and it has the negative effect of blocking new political forces from entering the legislature."


Furthermore, the Court explained, "Even if there are several minor parties, unless their number is excessive or they hinder the formation of national consensus required by the community or disrupt the stable functioning of the legislature, there is no rational reason to exclude minor parties from the allocation of proportional representation seats solely because they are minor parties."


In a supplementary opinion, Justices Kim Sanghwan and Jeong Jeongmi noted, "In the 22nd general election, the 3% threshold amounted to about 840,000 votes, which exceeds the total number of voters in Jeju Island." They added, "Such a vast number of citizens' voices being discarded at once does not align with the principles of democracy."


However, in a dissenting opinion, Justices Jeong Hyungsik and Jo Hanchang stated, "Today, extremist groups can rapidly consolidate support with simple and powerful messages that provoke anger and anxiety in society, more quickly than centrist parties." They warned, "If extremist groups with only minimal support are allowed to enter the legislature, their activities could be greatly encouraged."



The Constitutional Court emphasized, "We hope that this declaration of unconstitutionality will help ensure that the true will of the people is more faithfully reflected in the national decision-making process, strengthen the proportionality of election results, and lay the foundation for greater diversity in democracy."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing