'Giants of the 20th Century'
The Light and Shadow of Leadership Shown by Eight Leaders of the 20th Century
Who Will Lead as Heroes in an Age of Chaos?

War has once again become a part of daily reality, while invisible tariff wars and technological blockades are expanding into borderless conflicts. Democratic consensus is slow to form, and the international order is showing signs of fracture. In such turbulent times, the public always returns to the same question: Who will put an end to this chaos? All over the world, there is a renewed call for "strong leaders," and names like Trump and Putin rise to the surface of this collective desire. Whether these figures are heroes or not is not yet the point of judgment. The more important question is: Why does the world once again feel the need for heroes?

[How About This Book] Heroes May Be a 'Symptom' Created by Society View original image

Giants of the 20th Century brings this question from the past into the present. Through the stories of eight leaders who reshaped the world order in the twentieth century, the book examines both the impact a single individual can have on history and how history, in turn, shapes individuals. Wilson, Lenin, Hitler, Churchill, Roosevelt, Gandhi, Ben-Gurion, and Mao. Author Michael Mandelbaum does not reduce these figures to mere heroes or villains. Instead, he places them within the same analytical framework and calmly traces when great leadership becomes an achievement and when it turns into disaster.


The book's greatest virtue lies in separating the notion of "greatness" from moral judgment. Here, greatness is not another name for goodness. Rather, it refers to having a decisive impact on history. By this standard, it becomes possible for the architects of democracy and those responsible for genocide to appear in the same chapter. This may be uncomfortable, but it is precisely this discomfort that the book demands from its readers.


All eight leaders emerged during times of upheaval, after monarchies had weakened or collapsed. They gained power not through bloodlines, but through mobilization and persuasion, revolution and elections. They all shared confidence, energy, persistence, and the ability to captivate the masses with their words. Yet their outcomes were starkly different. Some leaders absorbed crises into institutions, while others exploited crises to drive destruction. The difference lay not so much in individual character, but in the way power operated and whether there were mechanisms in place to control it.


At this point, the book does not rely on the morality or goodwill of individual leaders. Instead, it focuses on the pathways through which individual decisions are amplified and reproduced-that is, the ways institutions, organizations, and the aspirations of the masses combine. Even leaders with the same confidence and decisiveness produce entirely different results depending on whether their actions operate within the frameworks of constitutions, parliaments, the press, and the judiciary, or whether they work to undermine those very frameworks. Giants of the 20th Century reveals the mechanics of power not by judging leaders, but by dissecting the conditions that supported them.


Roosevelt and Mao are the clearest examples illustrating this contrast. Both ruled for extended periods during times of national crisis and fundamentally reshaped their societies. However, Roosevelt translated crisis into institutions and policies, while Mao amplified crisis in the name of revolution. One strengthened institutions; the other overwhelmed them. This contrast is not meant to evaluate particular individuals, but rather to serve as an example of the conditions necessary for strong leadership to be permitted.

This book does not rely on the morality or goodwill of individual leaders. Instead, it focuses on the pathways through which individual decisions are amplified and reproduced, that is, the ways institutions, organizations, and the aspirations of the masses combine. Roosevelt and Mao Zedong are the clearest examples illustrating this contrast. Gemini generated image

This book does not rely on the morality or goodwill of individual leaders. Instead, it focuses on the pathways through which individual decisions are amplified and reproduced, that is, the ways institutions, organizations, and the aspirations of the masses combine. Roosevelt and Mao Zedong are the clearest examples illustrating this contrast. Gemini generated image

View original image

However, the book does not stop at comparing specific pairs. Churchill united the public with the language of national survival, while Gandhi built moral authority by rejecting violent mobilization. Ben-Gurion made ruthless decisions for the sake of survival, and Hitler transformed anger and victimhood into destructive charisma. The eight leadership styles do not represent a single model, but rather form a map of the various paths that can emerge in times of crisis.


As a result, the book leaves readers with a peculiar sense of discomfort. It prompts reflection on where the longing for heroes originates and when that desire turns into political choice. All of the giants of the twentieth century rose to the pinnacle of power by harnessing the expectations and anxieties of the masses. When those expectations were channeled through institutions, they led to national recovery; when they were focused on individuals, they led to irreversible catastrophe. This difference is not just a problem of the past, but a crossroads of choices that continues to repeat today.


At this point, Giants of the 20th Century poses a question for the present: Are we building a society that enables certain kinds of leaders, rather than simply asking what kind of leader we want? Heroes may not be a choice, but a symptom. The weaker institutions appear and the slower consensus forms, the more the public longs for a decisive face. And whether that face becomes salvation or disaster depends less on individual will and more on the surrounding structures.


This book does not teach how to lead a community. Rather, it shows when leadership saves a community and when it destroys it. The louder the calls for heroes in times of turmoil, the more often we must ask ourselves this question. The reason to read Giants of the 20th Century again today is that we are still living in the world they designed.



Giants of the 20th Century | Michael Mandelbaum | Translated by Hong Seokyun | Miraeui Chang | 512 pages | 29,000 KRW


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing