[Inside Chodong]Do All Roads Lead to 'Stock Prices'?... Greater Caution Needed for Tax Neutrality View original image

On the day when the KOSPI surpassed the 5,000 mark for the first time in history, the President once again expressed support for the so-called "Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act." The intention is to correct the practice of deliberately depressing stock prices ahead of inheritance or gifting in order to reduce tax burdens. While stock prices have often been referred to as the "face of a company," it is also true that there have been cases of stock price suppression prior to succession.


The challenge lies in the solution. Artificially depressing stock prices is clearly abnormal. However, it is worth carefully considering whether reforming the tax system is truly the most precise remedy for this issue. The main point of the recently discussed "Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act" is that, for listed companies with a price-to-book ratio (PBR) below 0.8, the valuation method used for unlisted companies would be applied instead of the stock price when calculating inheritance or gift taxes.


However, can low stock prices always be generalized as "intentional suppression"? In industries with uncertain outlooks or those that are capital-intensive, such as heavy industries, as well as in the highly volatile KOSDAQ market, structurally low PBRs are common. Many tax experts have pointed out in unison that "it is very difficult to conclude intentionality solely based on a low PBR" and that "applying the same figure to all companies is unreasonable." They argue that changing tax obligations based on a single indicator, without proving intent, is excessive. There is also a need to be wary of potential unintended side effects if a single indicator is used as the basis for a system without adequately filtering the various factors influencing stock price formation.


Another important point to consider is whether the issue of stock price suppression, which concerns the order of the capital market, should indeed be resolved through tax policy. If there is malicious disclosure or intentional stock price manipulation, this should be addressed under capital market laws. While taxes can serve as a policy tool, if they begin to be used as a direct mechanism to adjust the market, controversy over the loss of neutrality is inevitable. It should also be considered that if market participants begin to alter their management decisions or listing plans due to tax burdens, this in itself could lead to another form of market distortion.


Separate from the need to revise inheritance and gift taxes, it is also hard to ignore the impression that the current debate is overly focused on boosting stock prices. The moment the revision of inheritance and gift taxes starts to appear as part of a "stock market stimulus package" rather than a discussion for "tax justice," the legitimacy of the system may actually be undermined. While tax policy is one tool among many, even then, it should only be used as a last resort and not serve as an immediate lever to prop up stock prices.


There is no doubt that, for the Korean stock market to become more advanced, the practice of artificially suppressing stock prices must be eliminated. However, whether the solution should be a blanket legislative change to taxation based on a single indicator like the PBR is another matter. Strict post-facto sanctions for intentional stock price manipulation, a selective approach based on objective criteria, and a comprehensive review of the inheritance and gift tax system as a whole should all be pursued in tandem.



After the KOSPI 5000 milestone, the challenge for our stock market is not "faster gains" but the sustainable trust between the market and policy. Whether propping up stock prices through tax policy is the way to build that trust is something that should be calmly reconsidered at this moment when everyone is celebrating.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing