Calls for Reconsideration of ELS Fine Calculation Standards
Claims of "Human Rights Violations" Raised During Special Inspections

The National Financial Industry Labor Union has publicly opposed what it considers excessive sanctions imposed by financial authorities regarding the Hong Kong H Index-linked Equity-Linked Securities (ELS) misselling incident. The union also criticized the ongoing inspection process at some banks, claiming that certain employees are being subjected to tailored investigations and excessive accountability.


The National Financial Industry Labor Union held a press conference on the 28th in front of the Financial Supervisory Service headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul, shouting slogans to urge the resolution of the ELS incident and to condemn the oppressive inspections by the Financial Supervisory Service.

The National Financial Industry Labor Union held a press conference on the 28th in front of the Financial Supervisory Service headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul, shouting slogans to urge the resolution of the ELS incident and to condemn the oppressive inspections by the Financial Supervisory Service.

View original image

On the 28th, the National Financial Industry Labor Union held a press conference in front of the Financial Supervisory Service headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul, urging the resolution of the ELS incident and condemning the oppressive inspections by the Financial Supervisory Service. The union pointed out that responsibility for the Hong Kong ELS incident is being shifted solely onto frontline bank employees and the banks themselves.


Yoon Seokgu, head of the union, stated in his opening remarks, "The Financial Supervisory Service should be the final guardian of the financial industry, but it is now creating a climate of fear rather than proper supervision in the financial sector." He added, "The criteria for calculating ELS fines have been excessively expanded beyond the intent of the law and the principle of proportionality. If this becomes the norm, it could lead to an overall contraction of the financial industry, job insecurity, and reduced consumer choice."


The union argued that there are errors in the method used by the Financial Supervisory Service to calculate fines. Yoon stated, "Fines should be imposed in a way that anyone can understand and find reasonable," and criticized the current standards as excessively harsh and inconsistent with the intent and proportionality of the law.


Concerns were also raised about the impact of large fines on bank management and employment. Moon Seongchan, head of the union at Standard Chartered Bank Korea, the main seller of the Hong Kong ELS, said, "Excessive fines could prompt Standard Chartered Group, the parent company, to make the extreme decision to withdraw its retail banking business from Korea." He continued, "Punitive fines that do not meet international standards could push over 4,000 Standard Chartered Bank Korea employees to the brink and result in a national loss by damaging the diversity of the domestic financial ecosystem."


The union strongly criticized the inspection methods of the Financial Supervisory Service as well. They argued that the tailored investigations and psychological pressure during recent bank inspections amount to human rights violations.


Yoon stated, "The Financial Supervisory Service's high-handed investigations and psychological pressure are an abuse of power, not supervision," adding, "Supervisory authority is only legitimate when it is exercised with due process, proportionality, and respect for human dignity." He also noted that frontline staff are being repeatedly summoned and subjected to psychological pressure during the investigation process.


Meanwhile, the Financial Supervisory Service will hold its second disciplinary review committee on the Hong Kong ELS misselling case on the 29th. Attention is focused on the Financial Supervisory Service's next decision, especially after the court ruled against the plaintiffs in a misselling compensation lawsuit held ahead of the review, despite the agency having previously decided on fines totaling around 2 trillion won.


In fact, at the end of last year, the Financial Supervisory Service gave prior notice to five banks-KB Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, NH Nonghyup, and Standard Chartered Bank Korea-of its intention to impose fines and penalties totaling around 2 trillion won for their responsibility in the Hong Kong ELS misselling. However, due to the recent court ruling, legal controversy over the scale of the fines imposed by the Financial Supervisory Service has become inevitable.



The final amount of the fines will be determined through the disciplinary review committee and a resolution by the Financial Services Commission.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing