During President Lee Jaemyung's Tenure as Mayor of Seongnam
"Even a murderer can win with a party nomination, but even Confucius would lose without one"
A Clever Solution Needed to Ensure Equality of Votes

There have been calls for electoral system reforms to address the phenomenon in local elections where "even a murderer can win if nominated by a major party, but even Confucius would lose without a party nomination," and to improve the current state of single-party dominance or extreme swings in local councils.


On January 28, Lee Mi-ae, a member of the Special Committee on Political Reform at the National Assembly from the Democratic Party of Korea, and Jung Chun-saeng, a member of the Korea Innovation Party, held a forum at the National Assembly under the theme "30 Years of Local Autonomy: Evaluation and Challenges."


Attorney Ha Seung-soo, who has long advocated for electoral reform, gave a presentation at the event. Ha introduced an instance from 2018, when President Lee Jaemyung, then mayor of Seongnam, criticized the two-member constituency system-where two representatives are elected from a single district-as a "killing party, saving party" election in a radio interview. This, Ha explained, shows that even President Lee was aware of the problems posed by local councils being dominated by major party nominations.

On the 28th, a forum on "30 Years of Local Autonomy: Evaluation and Challenges" is being held at the National Assembly. Photo by Naju Seok

On the 28th, a forum on "30 Years of Local Autonomy: Evaluation and Challenges" is being held at the National Assembly. Photo by Naju Seok

View original image

Ha pointed out, "Local councils have become either 'single-party dominated councils' or 'swinging councils.'" He noted that in regions such as Daegu, North Gyeongsang, Gwangju, South Jeolla, and North Jeolla, a single party has maintained effective control. In contrast, areas like Seoul, Gyeonggi, Incheon, Busan, Ulsan, and South Gyeongsang have experienced significant swings between parties.


Swing Elections

In fact, during the 2018 local elections, the Democratic Party of Korea won 50.92% of the votes in the Seoul metropolitan council elections but secured 92.73% of the seats. The Liberty Korea Party, despite receiving 25.24% of the votes, won only 5.45% of the seats. In contrast, in the 2022 elections, the results were reversed: the People Power Party received 53.99% of the votes and took 67.86% of the seats, while the Democratic Party of Korea, with 40.98% of the votes, secured only 32.14% of the seats.


These results indicate that, rather than reflecting the will of voters, the characteristics of the electoral system lead to a disproportionate concentration of seats for a particular party. As a result, councils tilted to one side tend to be run by a single party without meaningful debate or discussion.


Single-Party Dominance Elections

Ha emphasized, "Local basic councils should be arenas where diverse political forces compete, but diversity is not being achieved." He pointed out that "in the 2022 local elections, 94.4% of successful candidates belonged to the two major parties." In particular, in two-member constituencies, either one party monopolized the seats or the two major parties split them between themselves.


This monopolistic structure by particular parties lowers the quality of legislative activities. Ha argued, "If one party holds more than two-thirds of the seats, policy competition and debate become impossible," adding, "Debate on policy is inevitably lost." He further explained, "In situations where a particular party's dominance is strong, party nominations inevitably determine electoral outcomes. If the nomination process is not democratic, legislative activities by council members will not be considered as criteria for nomination in the next election."


Possible Solutions

One consistently raised point regarding local election system reform is the need to ensure the equality (proportionality) of votes. The system must be designed so that residents' choices are directly reflected in the political structure.


Regarding this, Ha suggested, "While maintaining the single-member district system for constituencies, proportional representation seats should be allocated according to the percentage of votes each party receives to ensure vote equality. Additionally, a regional proportional representation system could replace the current single-member district system, dividing regions according to certain criteria and requiring each party to submit a proportional representation list for each region."



However, recognizing that local elections are approaching, he added, "If large-scale reform is difficult, we should consider increasing the proportion of proportional representation seats from the current 10% to 20-30%, and prioritize allocating proportional seats to parties whose seat share is lower than their vote share." He also argued, "For local government head elections, introducing a runoff voting system is necessary to ensure representativeness."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing