Network Usage Fees, Map Export, and Cloud Security Certification
U.S. Deputy Chief of Mission Sends Letter: "Do Not Discriminate Against Big Tech"
Ministry of Science and ICT Clarifies: "Unrelated to Tariff Increase Reasons"

There is analysis suggesting that South Korea's "digital regulatory barriers" may have played a role in U.S. President Donald Trump's announcement to restore tariffs on Korean products from 15% back to the pre-trade agreement level of 25%. It is possible that the U.S. government perceives South Korea's digital policies as discriminatory against American companies and is dissatisfied with the situation.

Trump's Surprise Tariff Hike: Are South Korea's "Digital Regulatory Barriers" Also to Blame? View original image

According to the Ministry of Science and ICT and other sources on January 28, James Heller, Deputy Chief of Mission at the U.S. Embassy in Korea, sent a letter on January 13 addressed primarily to Baek Kyunghoon, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Science and ICT. The letter was also sent for reference to Foreign Minister Cho Hyun, Minister of Trade, Industry and Energy Kim Jeonggwan, and Chairman of the Fair Trade Commission Joo Byungki, among others.


The letter reportedly urged the implementation of the pledge made in the joint fact sheet released after the Korea-U.S. summit at last year's APEC summit in Gyeongju, which stated that "the operation of U.S. big tech businesses in Korea will not be discriminated against." Given that the letter was sent about two weeks ago, it can be interpreted as a prior warning regarding the recent tariff hike.


The fact sheet at the time included an agreement to "ensure that U.S. companies are not discriminated against or face unnecessary barriers in laws and policies related to digital services, including network usage fees and online platform regulations, and to facilitate cross-border data transfers, including those related to location, reinsurance, and personal information."


This has been interpreted as the U.S. expressing dissatisfaction with the Korean government's recent moves to introduce various regulations and legislation in the digital sector. However, the Ministry of Science and ICT clarified the previous day, stating, "(The letter) primarily urges that U.S. companies not be discriminated against on digital issues," and drew a line, saying, "There is no direct connection with President Trump's claim that the Korean National Assembly has not enacted the laws necessary for implementing the Korea-U.S. trade agreement, which he cited as a reason for the tariff increase."

Trump's Surprise Tariff Hike: Are South Korea's "Digital Regulatory Barriers" Also to Blame? View original image
U.S. Expresses Discontent Over Digital Regulatory Barriers

The U.S. has long pressured South Korea over its digital policies. The United States Trade Representative (USTR), through its annual National Trade Estimate (NTE) report, has repeatedly cited South Korea's network usage fees, restrictions on exporting high-precision maps, and the Cloud Security Assurance Program (CSAP) as representative non-tariff barriers in the digital sector. Since the launch of the second Trump administration, the pressure to lift these regulations has intensified.


Specifically, the NTE report criticizes as "anti-competitive" the bill currently being discussed in the National Assembly that would require global content providers (CPs) to bear part of the network usage fees. The U.S. opposes calls for overseas platforms such as YouTube, which generate massive traffic, to pay fair compensation for network usage.


The requirement that government approval is needed to export high-precision maps to overseas servers is also seen as a disadvantage to U.S. companies. Currently, companies such as Google and Apple have submitted applications to the Korean government to transfer high-precision map data at a 1:5,000 scale to overseas servers, but the government has delayed its decision due to concerns over national security and reverse discrimination against domestic companies. The decision on map export is made through a consultative body involving relevant ministries, including the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, Ministry of National Defense, National Intelligence Service, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Unification, Ministry of Science and ICT, Ministry of the Interior and Safety, and Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy.


The CSAP certification system, required for entry into the public cloud market, is another digital regulatory barrier pointed out by the U.S. Cloud service providers must obtain CSAP certification to enter the public sector. Major U.S. cloud service providers such as Amazon Web Services (AWS), Microsoft, and Google Cloud have received the "Ha" grade CSAP security certification, but this only covers publicly available information such as tourism guides or website operations. Higher-level certification requires compliance with "physical network separation" requirements.



The USTR also points to restrictions on the overseas transfer of personal information of domestic users under the Personal Information Protection Act and the increasing scale of fines as additional digital barriers. Furthermore, the online platform fair trade law (Onple Law), which the government and ruling party are promoting, has been criticized as a form of prior regulation that could disadvantage U.S. companies. In addition, there have been criticisms from U.S. political circles that the Korean government's pressure on Coupang, which was involved in a large-scale personal information leak, constitutes excessive regulation of U.S. companies.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing