"KOSPI at a Crossroads: 7,000 or 3,500"
Calls for Stronger Investor Protection and Reactivation of Value-Up Policies

"The KOSPI is currently in the process of resolving its discount. We're only in the bottom of the fourth inning, so there is still a long way to go."


On January 27, the Korea Corporate Governance Forum warned that if the semiconductor cycle turns downward and capital market reforms stall, the KOSPI could plummet to 3,500. Conversely, the forum argued that if reforms continue, the KOSPI could reach the 6,000 or even 7,000 mark.


In a statement titled "Ten Key Tasks the Government Must Address to Complete Capital Market Reform," the forum said that the KOSPI stands at a crossroads between an era of 7,000 and a drop to 3,500. The Governance Forum, a non-profit association comprised of over 120 domestic and international members including financial professionals, legal experts, and academics, aims to advance the capital market through improvements in corporate governance.


First, the forum pointed out, "The KOSPI has doubled from the 2,500 level in May last year, yet its price-earnings ratio (PER) remains at 12 times." However, it added, "Is the KOSPI extremely undervalued? That is unlikely." Given the market's cyclical and economically sensitive industrial structure, the forum analyzed that this could be a 'peak earnings signal.'


The forum explained, "As a representative cyclical sector, the semiconductor industry sees its PER drop as it approaches peak earnings. The fact that Samsung Electronics' projected PER for 2026 is 8 times and SK Hynix's is 6 times suggests that their stock prices are not far from their earnings peak."


In particular, the forum warned that if the semiconductor cycle turns downward, it could directly impact the KOSPI, citing forecasts that a global semiconductor oversupply may begin at the end of this year. "If the semiconductor cycle turns and capital market reforms stall, the KOSPI could plunge to 3,500," the forum stated, emphasizing that even in the era of KOSPI 5,000, only continued corporate governance reforms will enable the index to reach the 6,000 or 7,000 level.


Accordingly, the forum presented ten key tasks. "Legislation on mandatory cancellation of treasury shares must be enacted immediately, with much stricter exceptions and a shorter grace period," the forum said. "The exception clause allowing for 'management purposes' such as introducing new technology or improving financial structure is highly problematic." The forum noted that some companies have already attempted to circumvent legislation by issuing exchangeable bonds (EBs) for treasury shares or by using relationships among controlling shareholders to swap shares.


The forum also called for a fundamental ban on subsidiary listings. "Korea has the highest number of 'double listings' in the world, where both parent and subsidiary companies are listed," the forum said, referencing President Lee Jaemyung's recent remark that "you shouldn't buy stocks with an 'L' in their name" and the recent case where LS Group halted the IPO of its sub-subsidiary Essex Solutions. The forum added that in exceptional cases where subsidiary listings are unavoidable, legal systems must protect the interests of parent company shareholders and ensure independent operation of the board of directors.


Additionally, the forum argued that capital market reform requires an organic combination of top-down legal and institutional improvements and bottom-up changes in corporate management and culture. It insisted that value-up policies with a degree of compulsion must be reactivated. The forum also recommended that independent and inside directors should not be distinguished, but instead, a proper director training program should be established, and an investor protection center modeled after Taiwan's system should be set up. In Taiwan, the Securities and Futures Investors Protection Center (SFIPC) operates with about 20 lawyers at its core, handling lawsuits to protect shareholders.


Other recommendations included improving the largely formal procedures of general shareholders' meetings, disclosing the decision-making process and results of the National Pension Service's Stewardship Committee's voting, introducing a "bear hug" mechanism to delist severely undervalued companies through mergers and acquisitions (M&A), prohibiting the abuse of comprehensive stock swaps, and establishing a specialized corporate law court similar to the Delaware Court of Chancery in the United States.



The forum concluded, "Ultimately, to fundamentally resolve corporate governance issues, alignment among four pillars-minority shareholders, the board of directors, management, and controlling shareholders-is necessary. If investor protection is assured, foreign capital will continue to flow in. The National Assembly and government should pursue strategies to raise the market's floor through capital market reform." The forum added, "If all ten key tasks are achieved, legal and institutional improvements are made, and controlling shareholders fundamentally change their attitude toward minority shareholders, it would also be worth considering a national debate on rationalizing inheritance and gift taxes."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing