Chu Mi-ae, Chairperson of the National Assembly's Legislation and Judiciary Committee, is striking the gavel at the plenary meeting of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee held at the National Assembly on January 7, 2026. Photo by Kim Hyunmin

Chu Mi-ae, Chairperson of the National Assembly's Legislation and Judiciary Committee, is striking the gavel at the plenary meeting of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee held at the National Assembly on January 7, 2026. Photo by Kim Hyunmin

View original image

The debate over the "systematic and textual review" system of the National Assembly's Legislation and Judiciary Committee has resurfaced. In an issue analysis report published on January 26, the National Assembly Research Service raised the need for reform or abolition of the system, stating, "While the Legislation and Judiciary Committee's systematic and textual review has the positive function of improving the completeness of bills, it also serves as a de facto veto point and causes legislative delays for controversial bills."


The systematic and textual review is a process in which the Legislation and Judiciary Committee examines the legal structure and wording of all bills that have passed their respective standing committees before they are submitted to the plenary session. Introduced in the 2nd National Assembly in 1951, it has been maintained for over 75 years, but is considered a unique feature of the Korean National Assembly that is rarely found in other parliaments, which generally adhere to a committee-centered approach.


The report pointed out that this system has repeatedly infringed upon the review authority of the relevant standing committees, as it has often gone beyond formal examination to amend the substantive content of bills. In practice, numerous controversial bills, such as the Information and Communications Network Act, the Capital Markets Act, and the Toxic Chemicals Control Act, have had their content altered or been held up for extended periods at the Legislation and Judiciary Committee stage, fueling controversy.


In particular, the issue of legislative delay is evident in the numbers. In the 21st National Assembly, the average duration for the Legislation and Judiciary Committee's systematic and textual review of general bills was 48.1 days. However, for bills where the relevant standing committee requested referral to the plenary session due to "delays in systematic and textual review," the bills remained pending at the committee for an average of 216 days. Some bills were held up for over 700 days and were ultimately discarded when the session expired.


The report identified political interests surrounding the chairmanship of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee and the unique composition of the committee as the background for these issues. As of the first half of the 22nd National Assembly, about two-thirds of the committee members had legal backgrounds, and bills directly related to the legal profession or judicial reform were repeatedly delayed by the committee, leading to criticism that "the committee represents the interests of a specific profession."



Accordingly, the National Assembly Research Service proposed three alternatives. First, abolishing the systematic and textual review at the Legislation and Judiciary Committee and having it conducted at the standing committee stage. Second, splitting the Legislation and Judiciary Committee into a Judiciary Committee and a Legislation Committee, or establishing a separate special committee dedicated to systematic and textual review. Third, maintaining the current system but strictly limiting the scope of review and strengthening mechanisms to prevent delays.



The report emphasized, "The legislative process must ensure both better laws and the values of democracy and efficiency," and added, "It is necessary to redesign the system so that the systematic and textual review functions as a technical support procedure, not as a gateway that blocks legislation."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing