Loan Suitability and Internal Control Issues Over Unlisted Shares as Collateral
Statement Denies Allegations, Asserts "Standard Financial Investment Operation"

SK Securities has come under controversy after providing a large-scale stock-backed loan to Oh Changseok, Chairman of Mugunghwa Trust, using shares of an unlisted company as collateral. However, SK Securities maintains that the entire process, from procedure to collateral, was a "legally sound and standard financial investment business operation."


On the morning of January 27, SK Securities issued a statement saying, "The three loans extended to Mugunghwa Trust were carried out in accordance with laws and internal regulations, following legitimate procedures," and added, "The loans were made under proper risk management based on sound financial status and external evaluations." This response comes amid growing controversy that SK Securities' unusual stock-backed lending to Chairman Oh has put the principal at risk of total loss, with allegations that the company's internal control systems failed to function.

SK Securities Under Fire for Large-Scale Mugunghwa Trust Loan...Claims "All Procedures Were Legal" View original image

Previously, in June 2023, SK Securities arranged a 150 billion won loan for Chairman Oh, owner of Mugunghwa Trust, using shares of the trust company as collateral, and lent him 86.9 billion won. Immediately after the loan, SK Securities structured the unlisted stock-backed loan and resold approximately 44 billion won of it to institutional and individual clients.


The collateral for the loan was reported to be a controlling stake in Mugunghwa Trust (50% plus 1 share) held by Chairman Oh. Five months after the loan was executed, an Event of Default (EOD) occurred. However, because the collateral was illiquid unlisted shares, SK Securities was unable to proceed with measures such as forced sales to recover the debt. As a result, some investors were unable to recover their principal, and SK Securities provided support to clients by advancing 30% of their investment (13.2 billion won) as provisional payments.


SK Securities is currently seeking to sell the controlling stake in Mugunghwa Trust in order to recover the loan. In addition, to address clients' liquidity concerns, the company provided a portion of the investment as provisional payments. Furthermore, by the end of last year, SK Securities set aside more than 80% of the loan amount as loan loss provisions.


In its statement, SK Securities addressed the issue of not going through a board resolution by explaining, "The loan was executed after approval by the internal Risk Management Executive Committee." Since 2016, when financial authorities allowed unlisted stock-backed loans, major securities firms have entered the market, and SK Securities also revised its internal rules regarding unlisted stock-backed loans after legal review.


The company also emphasized that, at the time of the loan, it had obtained valuations of the collateral and company value from an accounting firm and determined that the business was profitable before proceeding with the loan. SK Securities stated, "At the time the loan was executed, Mugunghwa Trust was financially stable, and in 2018, trust companies such as Shinhan Asset Trust and Woori Asset Trust were sold at high prices (PBR 3.1-4.6 times, PER 11-13 times), making the trust industry a popular sector."


According to SK Securities, the first loan was executed in 2019 and was fully repaid early within two months. For the second loan, executed in 2021 (based on the company's 2020 year-end performance), Mugunghwa Trust ranked 8th in the industry in operating revenue, posting an operating profit of 23.2 billion won and a net profit of 30.7 billion won. In 2022, the company recorded sales of 148.6 billion won, net profit of 37.4 billion won, and a Net Capital Ratio (NCR)-a key capital adequacy indicator-of 473%, well above the regulatory recommendation.


SK Securities explained, "Safety mechanisms were in place for collateral valuation and risk management," adding, "We conservatively assessed company value through major domestic accounting and appraisal firms rather than internal evaluation, and secured a collateral coverage ratio of 160-205% relative to the appraised value." The contract also reportedly included provisions allowing for immediate declaration of EOD and enforcement of collateral rights if the borrower's NCR fell below 300% or if the collateralized stake dropped below a majority (50% plus 1 share).



The company also dismissed allegations of misselling. SK Securities stated, "To proactively protect clients, provisional payments were made with the consent of all clients," and added, "A thorough internal review of the sales process and supporting documentation found no evidence of misselling, and all procedures required by the Financial Consumer Protection Act were fully followed." The company continued, "All circumstances regarding the stock-backed loan are systematically reported to supervisory authorities, making intentional concealment impossible," and noted, "As the process of selling the controlling stake is ongoing, there are inevitable limitations on the information that can be disclosed publicly at this time."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing