Prosecutors Investigate 4-Trillion-Won Flour Price-Fixing
CJ CheilJedang Cooperates via Leniency, Provides Collusion Evidence
Exemption from Prosecution... Possibility of FTC Referral Remains

As prosecutors continue their investigation into flour price-fixing among milling companies worth over 4 trillion won, it has been confirmed that CJ CheilJedang has utilized the "leniency program" (self-reporting and immunity/mitigation system). Observers suggest that, depending on the level of cooperation with the investigation, CJ CheilJedang may be able to avoid "judicial risk" related to the flour price-fixing case.


According to legal and food industry sources on the 27th, CJ CheilJedang submitted internal documents and details of the collusion process to prosecutors while applying for leniency during the investigation into flour price-fixing involving seven companies, including Daehan Flour Mills and Sajodongaone.


The prosecution stated in its indictment that CJ CheilJedang, Daehan Flour Mills, Sajodongaone, and others, through a search and seizure, were found to have agreed on the timing, magnitude, and occurrence of flour price changes for supply to the domestic market from around the end of 2019 until October of last year, and jointly engaged in unfair competition to restrict other competitors. The prosecution further noted that, based on the materials and statements obtained so far, there is sufficient evidence to suspect that these companies engaged in collusion.

[Exclusive] CJ CheilJedang Applies for Leniency in 4 Trillion Won Flour Price-Fixing Case... Aiming for Prosecution Exemption View original image

It appears that the prosecution identified specific items to seize based on CJ CheilJedang's leniency application. In the search warrant request, prosecutors asked the court for permission to seize meeting minutes, records, audio recordings, and other materials related to meetings about flour price-fixing, as well as documents regarding flour price increases and decreases, basic data on flour price calculations, sales performance data, raw material purchase records, and inventory and distribution information.


Legal experts believe it is unlikely that prosecutors would have included information about audio recordings related to the flour price-fixing in the search warrant without prior knowledge. A lawyer who previously served as a chief prosecutor stated, "In collusion cases, it is difficult for prosecutors to obtain confidential information such as meeting minutes or recordings without leniency. Depending on the level of evidence provided or cooperation with the investigation, leniency applicants may be exempted from prosecution, so once an investigation begins, some companies come forward voluntarily."


According to Supreme Prosecutors' Office regulations, the first applicant for criminal leniency is exempted from prosecution, while the second applicant receives a 50% reduction in sentencing recommendations. Analysts believe that CJ CheilJedang's decision to seek leniency in the flour price-fixing case is influenced by the recent sugar price-fixing scandal, which involved a department head being indicted and detained over a case worth more than 3 trillion won. Due to the sugar price-fixing, CJ CheilJedang executives and the company itself were put on trial for violating the Fair Trade Act. However, in the flour price-fixing case, prosecutors have not requested arrest warrants for CJ CheilJedang executives or employees.

[Exclusive] CJ CheilJedang Applies for Leniency in 4 Trillion Won Flour Price-Fixing Case... Aiming for Prosecution Exemption View original image

The issue is that the prosecution's investigation and the Fair Trade Commission's (FTC) probe are proceeding on separate tracks. In March 2024, the FTC began investigating CJ CheilJedang, Samyang Corporation, and Daehan Sugar Manufacturing for "sugar price-fixing allegations," and expanded the probe in October of last year to include "flour price-fixing" by CJ CheilJedang and milling companies. Sanctions by the FTC regarding the sugar price-fixing case are expected to be decided at a full commission meeting next month.



Even if CJ CheilJedang actively cooperates with the prosecution and is exempted from indictment, if other companies such as Daehan Flour Mills cooperate with the FTC first, CJ CheilJedang may lose its priority in the leniency process, leading to a referral to prosecutors and the imposition of fines. According to the Fair Trade Act, during the FTC investigation stage, the first and second leniency applicants are exempted from referral to prosecutors and receive a 100% and 50% reduction in fines, respectively. An official familiar with the FTC stated, "As far as I know, the FTC's investigation into the flour price-fixing case is not yet complete. Depending on the results, the FTC could refer the company for prosecution, creating a difficult situation where the prosecutors may not indict."

[Exclusive] CJ CheilJedang Applies for Leniency in 4 Trillion Won Flour Price-Fixing Case... Aiming for Prosecution Exemption View original image

Meanwhile, CJ CheilJedang and others were also found to have engaged in flour price-fixing in 2006 and were fined a total of 43.4 billion won by the FTC.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing