The court has ruled that a one-month suspension imposed on a senior government official for applying criteria not specified in the job posting to select a particular candidate in the recruitment process for administrative staff at overseas diplomatic missions is justified. On November 19, 2025, the 8th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge Yang Sunjoo) ruled against the plaintiff in case 2025GuHap53808, in which senior official A filed a lawsuit against the Ministry of Foreign Affairs seeking to overturn the one-month suspension.


Image to aid understanding of the article. Pixabay

Image to aid understanding of the article. Pixabay

View original image

[Facts]

Mr. A is a senior official at an overseas diplomatic mission and serves as the chairperson of the personnel committee. During the recruitment process for administrative staff, Mr. A received the application documents of 24 candidates and, without following the required personnel committee review, unilaterally shortlisted five candidates as successful applicants in the document screening stage. Applicants B and C tied for first place in the interview stage, based on the scoring method that excluded the highest and lowest scores. Without a personnel committee review, Mr. A selected B as the final successful candidate, citing "work continuity and stability" as the reasons. B was a contract worker already employed at the diplomatic mission.

The Board of Audit and Inspection found that, during the document screening stage, Mr. A allowed candidates whose qualifications were unclear to pass, while those who met the requirements were eliminated. In the interview stage, Mr. A was criticized for giving preferential treatment to B by applying the arbitrary criterion of "work continuity," which was not mentioned in the job posting.


The Ministry of Foreign Affairs imposed a three-month suspension on Mr. A. The Appeals Review Committee of the Ministry of Personnel Management reduced the suspension to one month, citing Mr. A's remorse. Mr. A contested this decision by filing a lawsuit to overturn the disciplinary action.


[Court Ruling]

The court found the one-month suspension to be justified. The court stated, "Even if Mr. A had consulted with the administrative secretary, it cannot be justified that candidates with unclear qualifications, including B, were selected, while other qualified candidates were eliminated based on factors such as age." The court also pointed out, "Although the job posting specified that there would be an interview and written test, in reality, the results of these assessments were not used at all, and instead, the criterion of 'work continuity and stability,' which was not mentioned in the posting, was considered." It was also acknowledged that Mr. A finalized the selection of B, even though the secretary reported that "selecting B instead of C, considering the written test scores and other factors, would be unfair." The court noted, "Mr. A himself admitted during the appeals review process that he did not individually review the qualifications of the applicants."


The court explained, "Originally, the case was classified as 'serious misconduct and gross negligence,' resulting in a three-month suspension, which was then reduced to one month." The court concluded that the disciplinary action could not be considered excessively harsh or an abuse of discretion.



Kim Jisoo, The Law Journal Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing