Fair Trade Commission Orders Affinity to Halt Acquisition of Lotte Rental Shares

The Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) has rejected the proposed merger between SK Rent-a-Car and Lotte Rental, the top two companies in the car rental market. The commission determined that the merger would significantly restrict competition, raising concerns about potential price increases and other negative impacts.


On January 26, the KFTC announced that it had reached this decision after reviewing the proposed acquisition, in which Affinity Equity Partners, a private equity fund manager and owner of SK Rent-a-Car, sought to acquire a 63.5% stake in Lotte Rental.


The KFTC explained, "After reviewing the car rental market by dividing it into short-term rentals (less than one year) and long-term rentals (one year or more), we found concerns about restricted competition in both segments."


In the short-term car rental market, the combined market share of Lotte Rental and SK Rent-a-Car was 29.3% (mainland) and 21.3% (Jeju) as of the end of 2024. However, the KFTC noted that most other competitors are small and medium-sized businesses with minimal individual market shares.


Therefore, the commission judged that the merger would "intensify the polarization of the short-term car rental market, resulting in one dominant conglomerate and many small businesses," and that "with the disappearance of competition among major companies, there would be significant negative effects such as price increases (rental fees)."


Regarding the short-term car rental market in Jeju, the KFTC pointed out, "Due to the total car rental quota system, new market entry and fleet expansion by existing operators are restricted, making it even less likely for new major competitors to emerge." The commission thus concluded that the merger would likely lower the level of effective competition.


In the long-term car rental market, the combined market share of the two companies reached 38.3% as of the end of 2024. While there are a few relatively large capital companies and many smaller competitors, the KFTC determined that these companies do not possess competitive capabilities comparable to Lotte Rental and SK Rent-a-Car.


KFTC Blocks SK Rent-a-Car and Lotte Rental Merger Over Price Hike Concerns View original image

The KFTC particularly noted that capital companies are subject to the "core business ratio restriction" under the Specialized Credit Finance Business Act, which prevents them from holding more long-term rental vehicles than lease vehicles. As a result, they cannot freely expand their long-term rental operations, which are considered ancillary work.


Additionally, the KFTC emphasized that in the long-term car rental market-where vehicles are rented for extended periods and later sold as used cars-linkages with maintenance and used car sales are especially important. The commission considered that Lotte Rental and SK Rent-a-Car have a significant advantage over capital companies in these areas.


Lee Byunggeon, Director General of the Mergers and Acquisitions Division at the KFTC, stated, "A key consideration was the very high risk that effective competition would disappear due to the merger of two directly competing car rental companies," adding, "It would be difficult for a new effective competitor to emerge in a short period of time."


Accordingly, the KFTC decided to prohibit Affinity from acquiring shares in Lotte Rental.


The KFTC stressed that, as a rule, structural remedies are imposed in cases of significant competitive restriction. Considering the nature of private equity funds, which typically aim for a buyout after a certain period, the commission concluded that behavioral remedies such as price increase restrictions would not adequately address the harm caused by this merger. Therefore, it determined that prohibiting the share acquisition through a structural remedy was appropriate.


In August 2024, Affinity, a Hong Kong-based private equity fund that acquired SK Rent-a-Car, signed a contract through its affiliate special purpose company, Carina Transportation Group, to acquire a 63.5% stake in Lotte Rental for approximately 1.8 trillion won on March 11 last year and filed a pre-merger notification with the KFTC.


Affinity argued during the review process that the car rental market is diversifying and that competitive restrictions are not significant. The firm also proposed corrective measures, such as capping short-term rental rates below the consumer price index growth rate for a set period, and requested approval of the merger on these conditions. However, the KFTC did not accept these proposals.



This case drew attention as the first instance in which a private equity fund sought KFTC review for a merger between the top two companies in the same industry.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing