The court has ruled that the one-month suspension imposed on a Ministry of Foreign Affairs official, who selected the final successful candidate based on criteria not specified in the job posting, is lawful.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs Officer Hired Staff Using Unlisted Criteria; Court Rules One-Month Suspension Lawful View original image

According to the legal community on January 26, the Seoul Administrative Court's Division 8 for Administrative Cases (Presiding Judge Yang Sunjoo) ruled against the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by Officer A of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, who sought to overturn a one-month suspension imposed by the Minister of Foreign Affairs.


Officer A, who served as the chair of the personnel committee during the hiring of a professional administrative staff member at a consulate general, instructed that five out of 24 applicants be allowed to pass the document screening stage and proceed to the written exam and interview without a review by the personnel committee. After compiling the scores from the written exam and interview, both Candidate B and Candidate C ranked first. However, Officer A was found to have ordered the hiring of Candidate B without a committee review, citing "continuity and stability of work" as the reason.


Following an audit by the Board of Audit and Inspection, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs pursued disciplinary action, citing a breach of fairness. The Central Disciplinary Committee initially decided on a three-month suspension, which was later reduced to one month by the Appeals Review Committee. Officer A argued that the decision was excessive, stating that it was made in consultation with the secretary and only took practical circumstances into account.


However, the court did not accept this argument. The court pointed out that Officer A admitted to not "individually reviewing" whether each applicant met the qualification requirements during the document screening stage. It determined that even if there had been consultation with the secretary, this did not resolve the procedural flaws. The court also noted that although the job posting stated that a "written exam" would be conducted, the results did not appear to have been utilized, and that "continuity and stability of work" were not criteria included in the qualifications listed in the posting.



The court stated, "Considering that the hiring of Candidate B was decided despite the secretary's concerns about fairness, it is reasonable to view this as a violation of the duty of good faith," adding, "It is difficult to objectively consider the one-month suspension as a clear abuse or overreach of discretionary power."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing