[Economy Pulse] IEEPA Tariffs Will Not Be Automatically Refunded Even If Ruled Illegal View original image

Trade authorities and businesspeople around the world are closely monitoring the final decision of the U.S. Supreme Court regarding the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA). The ruling, initially expected last year, has been postponed three times this year. At the core of this decision is the interpretation of the powers of the President and Congress over trade policy as stipulated by the U.S. Constitution and federal law. The case is further complicated by a range of issues, including the economic ripple effects caused by the unilateral imposition of high tariffs and the potential refund of tariffs amounting to 150 billion dollars.


Many media outlets and experts have pointed out that President Trump invoked the IEEPA excessively. However, it is difficult to predict the Supreme Court's ruling. President Trump and senior officials have frequently raised concerns that a ruling of unconstitutionality could undermine the "America First" foreign policy and impose a significant fiscal burden. They have also threatened to reinstate tariffs through Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act (the national security clause), among other measures.


During oral arguments, Supreme Court justices reportedly expressed skepticism toward the administration's interpretation of the IEEPA. The repeated postponements of the ruling may indicate that the justices need more time to deliberate on the scope of the decision. The court may also be seriously considering the challenges the Treasury Department could face in promptly securing refunds totaling up to 150 billion dollars.


Even if the IEEPA tariffs are ultimately ruled illegal, importers can only secure refund eligibility if they have properly followed the claim procedures within the deadline. If the refund amount significantly exceeds the cost of filing a claim, importers should be careful not to miss the deadline. In this regard, the U.S. Court of International Trade (CIT) clarified last year that only by filing a lawsuit can claimants fully secure their rights to a refund. Above all, to minimize the ripple effects, the Supreme Court may include partial rather than full refunds in its final ruling. Furthermore, to prevent fiscal turmoil and overwhelming the customs authorities, the court may also restrict retroactive refund claims.


Until now, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) has operated both a paper-based manual payment system and an electronic customs clearance system. However, as of February 6, all processes will be fully transitioned to the new digital refund system (ACE). After this date, CBP will completely stop accepting paper documents. To receive electronic refunds, importers must register before February 6.


This is due to three main technical, practical, and legal reasons. First, if not registered in ACE in advance, it is impossible to link past customs payment data, which was handled manually, to ACE. This is because there would be no ACE account to electronically match refund applications.


Second, practical considerations cannot be ignored. If the IEEPA is ruled unconstitutional and a massive number of refund claims-potentially amounting to hundreds of billions of dollars-are filed simultaneously, CBP is likely to refuse to process claims that are not registered in the electronic system, citing the inability to retrieve data. Unlike the Korea Customs Service, the U.S. CBP is not known for its customer service.


Third, legal factors could also hinder refunds. If the IEEPA is ruled unconstitutional, importers must file objections to receive refunds. After the full transition to ACE, all objections and customs corrections must be submitted exclusively through the Document Imaging System (DIS) within ACE. If not registered in ACE, claimants may have to file civil lawsuits. Exporters may end up bearing the burden of years-long delays in refunds due to the required pre-review period (typically several months) and adjustments to the customs bond under the U.S. customs settlement system.


Regardless of ACE registration, there will likely be many cases where refund claims are not possible. If exporters shipped to the U.S. under "Delivered Duty Paid (DDP)" terms, the U.S. importer, in principle, holds the right to claim IEEPA tariff refunds. This is because, administratively, the importer is considered to have paid the tariffs, even if the exporter actually bore the cost. Last year, many companies absorbed the tariffs themselves to maintain their sales networks in the U.S. In such cases, exporters will need to negotiate with importers for refunds or pursue civil lawsuits based on private contracts.



Jung Ing-gyo, Professor of International Trade at Inha University (Former Director-General for Trade Negotiations, Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy)


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing