Inevitable Trial Delays as Revision Deadline Missed
Increased Confusion Among Inheritance Dispute Parties
Amendment Bills by Kim Hankyu and Park Jiwon Among Those Pending

The Constitutional Court has ruled that certain provisions of the Civil Act related to the statutory reserved portion (yuryubun) are inconsistent with the Constitution, setting a deadline for revision by the end of 2025. However, as the National Assembly missed this deadline, the relevant provisions have lost their effect, resulting in a legislative vacuum. Courts, which had suspended related trials while awaiting legislative action, now face difficulties. Confusion among litigants is also increasing. Although numerous amendment bills are pending in the National Assembly, criticism is mounting that the delay in legislation is undermining citizens' property rights and the stability of judicial procedures.


‘Turning a Blind Eye’: National Assembly’s Inaction Creates Statutory Reserved Portion Legislative Vacuum View original image
Provisions That Have Lost Effect

In April 2024, the Constitutional Court found the following legislative omissions unconstitutional: △ the absence of provisions specifying reasons for disqualification from receiving the statutory reserved portion (Article 1112, Items 1 to 3), and △ the failure to apply Article 1008-2 of the Civil Act, which concerns the contributory share, to the statutory reserved portion (Article 1118).


The Constitutional Court stated, "Recognizing the statutory reserved portion for heirs who have abandoned the decedent for a long period or have repeatedly committed immoral acts such as mental or physical abuse is contrary to the legal sentiment and common sense of the general public. Therefore, it is unreasonable that Article 1112 of the Civil Act does not separately specify grounds for loss of the statutory reserved portion," and ruled this part unconstitutional. The court also stated, "Article 1118 of the Civil Act does not provide for the application of Article 1008-2 concerning the contributory share to the statutory reserved portion. As a result, if a contributing heir who has supported the decedent for many years or helped form the estate receives part of the property as a gift from the decedent, this gifted property is still included in the base amount for calculating the statutory reserved portion. Consequently, the contributing heir is placed in an unfair and unreasonable situation where they must return the gifted property in response to a claim for return of the statutory reserved portion by a non-contributing heir." The court also ruled this part unconstitutional.

Numerous Pending Statutory Reserved Portion Cases

Until the revision deadline, courts had scheduled trial dates for many cases directly affected by the provisions requiring amendment, assuming that the law would be revised in time. Many panels chose to postpone hearings if both parties agreed. A lawyer who previously served as a family court chief judge explained, "Since the law has not been amended, and the applicable legal principles no longer exist, we have no choice but to wait."


The children of "Buwon Industries," who were involved in a family abduction case in the past, have also been engaged in statutory reserved portion litigation for seven years. This case, filed in January 2019, was scheduled for a verdict in February 2024, but the hearing was reopened. After the Constitutional Court's decision in April that year, only several mediation attempts have been made.


There are also ongoing corporate-related cases in court, although no trial dates have been set. One such case involves the family of BYC, an underwear and clothing manufacturing company. The spouse of the late former BYC Chairman Han Youngdae, as well as his other children, filed a lawsuit against BYC Chairman Han Seokbeom seeking the return of the statutory reserved portion from the inheritance of the late chairman. The complaint was filed in December 2022, and the case has been ongoing for more than three years.


A lawyer specializing in family law and a former presiding judge stated, "Although the Constitutional Court's decision specifies that the existing provisions have lost effect, it does not deny the statutory reserved portion itself. Therefore, it is not possible to postpone proceedings indefinitely, and in some cases, trials continue under the existing system." However, he also said, "Since it is unclear how the legislative improvements will turn out, the trials are proceeding with potential changes in mind, which naturally causes concern."

National Assembly Neglects Citizens' Property Rights

There is growing criticism over the National Assembly's failure to meet the deadline set by the Constitutional Court. Statutory reserved portion lawsuits are family property disputes that involve significant costs and considerable psychological distress for the parties, yet the National Assembly has not fulfilled its responsibilities. One family law specialist commented, "As a constitutional institution, the National Assembly may be seen as not respecting the decisions of another constitutional institution, the Constitutional Court." He added, "The National Assembly needs to reflect on its original responsibilities as a constitutional body."


An amendment to the Civil Act regarding the statutory reserved portion, reflecting discussions by the Ministry of Justice's Special Committee on Family Law, has been proposed in the National Assembly. Assemblyman Kim Hankyu (Judicial Research and Training Institute, 31st class) of the Democratic Party of Korea sponsored the bill. The amendment expands the scope of disqualification from inheritance not only to direct ascendants but also to direct descendants, spouses, and all heirs. It also strengthens protection for contributing heirs. When calculating the statutory reserved portion, if a contributory share has already been determined, it must first be deducted from the base property before calculating the statutory reserved portion, and the right-holder of the contributory share is guaranteed this amount. The method of return is also unified as a monetary return, and the amendment is retroactively applied to inheritances commencing on or after April 25, 2024.


In addition to the bill sponsored by Assemblyman Kim, several other amendments are pending. Assemblymen Kwon Chilsung, Baek Hyeryeon (29th class), and Park Ji-won of the Democratic Party have also proposed amendments to the Civil Act. These bills also introduce provisions for disqualification from the statutory reserved portion and apply the calculation of contributory shares to the statutory reserved portion.



Park Suyeon, Legal Times Reporter

An Jaemyung, Legal Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing