Fair Trade Commission Imposes Fines on Four Major Banks for LTV Collusion
Commission Finds LTV Information Sharing Restricted Competition in Mortgage Loans
Banks Respond: "Difficult to Accept, Considering Administrative Litigation"

Banks Express "Deep Regret, Considering Administrative Litigation" Over 270 Billion Won Collusion Fine View original image

The Fair Trade Commission has imposed a large-scale fine on the four major banks for colluding on the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio. The banks have stated that they find it difficult to accept the Commission’s decision and are prepared to proceed with administrative litigation if necessary.


On January 21, the Fair Trade Commission announced its decision to impose a fine of approximately 272 billion won on the four major banks-KB Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, and Woori-after finding that they shared LTV information and used it to restrict competition in the real estate secured loan market.


The Commission concluded, after a plenary session, that from March 2022 to March 2024, these four banks exchanged information related to real estate secured loans for households and businesses, including LTV ratios, and subsequently adjusted their LTV ratios so that there would be little difference from other banks.


The Fair Trade Commission determined that this series of actions constituted an exchange of information regarding transaction terms or payment conditions, which substantially restricted competition. This was deemed a violation of Article 40, Paragraph 1, Subparagraph 9 of the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act, as well as Article 44, Paragraph 2, Subparagraph 3 of its Enforcement Decree.


The banks involved have strongly objected to the Commission’s decision. A representative from one of the four major banks stated, “It is difficult to accept the Fair Trade Commission’s decision. The key issue is not just the exchange of information, but whether consumer interests were harmed by what is being called collusion. We do not see it that way.”


Another bank official commented, “From an operational perspective, we referenced this information to review the appropriateness of pricing, so we are perplexed by the conclusion that customer interests were harmed. There are also numerous meetings led by the government where information is exchanged, so it is unclear how this situation is different from those.”


The four major banks have already each contracted with law firms and are reviewing administrative litigation. Another banking industry representative emphasized, “We are currently conducting various discussions through our law firms, but since it is difficult to accept the outcome, administrative litigation is a natural next step. However, since we have not yet received the official written decision from the Fair Trade Commission, we will determine additional procedures after it is received.”



The Fair Trade Commission also expects that the banks will proceed with administrative litigation. A Commission official stated, “The majority of institutions that have received our penalty decisions have proceeded with administrative litigation, and we believe the banks will be no different.” The legal community expects that if litigation begins, it could proceed through the first trial, appeal, and up to the Supreme Court, potentially taking several years to reach a final conclusion.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing