[The Editors' Verdict]There Is No Such Thing as a Free Lunch View original image

It is common to hear people say, "It feels like my smartphone is eavesdropping on my conversations." For example, after talking with a friend about Tokyo, you suddenly see ads for trips to Japan, or after discussing financial strategies, you frequently encounter cryptocurrency ads. It is not easy to dismiss these suspicions as completely unfounded. In January 2025, Apple paid a $95 million (approximately KRW 140 billion) settlement to some customers. This was due to a class action lawsuit claiming that Apple's artificial intelligence (AI) assistant Siri had eavesdropped on user conversations. The complaint included examples involving Nike shoes and Italian restaurants, stating that after discussing these topics, the user's iPhone began displaying related ads. Although Apple paid the settlement, it did not admit to the eavesdropping allegations.


In 2024, promotional materials from Cox Media Group (CMG), a company well known as a Facebook marketing partner, were leaked, sparking similar controversy. The materials claimed that smartphone microphones were being used to collect conversations and target ads accordingly. Targeted advertising is a marketing strategy that analyzes a user's gender, age, interests, and search history to deliver customized ads. CMG explained that the content in question was somewhat exaggerated. Facebook, Google, and Amazon also stated that they have never permitted such advertising practices. Although all the big tech companies deny these claims, suspicions persist. Of course, it is possible that the big tech companies are telling the truth. Some point out that, even if collecting and using voice data for advertising is technically possible, it is not particularly effective. Smartphones are often kept in a bag or pocket, and even if recording were to happen 24 hours a day, factors like background noise and sleep hours mean that real-time monitoring and analysis would have limited value.


Targeted advertising that utilizes consumer data such as age, gender, current location, and past purchase history tends to have high advertising efficiency and is relatively expensive. Pixabay

Targeted advertising that utilizes consumer data such as age, gender, current location, and past purchase history tends to have high advertising efficiency and is relatively expensive. Pixabay

View original image

So how exactly do smartphones seem to read our minds and preferences to deliver such perfectly tailored ads? In reality, there are many ways to track individuals without eavesdropping on their conversations. Simply purchasing and activating a smartphone makes you a target for tracking. Every activated device is assigned a unique advertising ID, something like "K261-A14-24H." This ID can be shared across multiple applications and services. That is why, if you search for "running shoes" on Naver, you will later see shoe ads on Instagram or community sites as well. Not only your search history, but also factors like your location, time, and the type of device you are using (whether it's a laptop or a smartphone) influence which ads you see.


As consumers, we do have some means to resist. For example, Android phone users can delete their advertising ID in the settings. iPhone users can use the "Ask App Not to Track" option. However, these measures are unlikely to be satisfying. Deleting your advertising ID does not remove ads altogether; you will simply be exposed to ads that have nothing to do with your history or preferences. In most cases, you are more likely to encounter low-quality and provocative ads. Without an advertising ID, it becomes difficult to deliver effective ads, making advertisers hesitant to invest heavily. Since they cannot target their audience, the advertising space becomes dominated by cheap ads that have a higher chance of being clicked immediately.



Either way, users end up facing discomfort. They may be seduced into overspending by precisely targeted ads, or they may block tracking and suffer from the nuisance of poor-quality ads. This applies to any "free" service, such as free internet, free apps, or free social networking services (SNS). Users of free internet services are essentially paying with their thoughts and preferences as data. Indeed, there is no such thing as a free lunch.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing