[Reporter’s Notebook] The Constitutional Question Raised by the Acting Police Commissioner General View original image

"For rallies where hate speech is a concern, we will partially restrict the march route and, in case of violations, hold those responsible through investigations." This is the police response plan to hate rallies announced by Yoo Jaesung, Acting Commissioner General of the Korean National Police Agency, during a regular press briefing on December 18. By positioning the police as preemptive blockers rather than managers of rallies, this statement poses a significant risk to constitutional values.


The Constitution of the Republic of Korea explicitly guarantees the freedom of assembly and association and prohibits permits or censorship. The freedom of assembly is not merely the right for people to gather, but also includes the right to decide for themselves when, where, and how to express their opinions. The route of a march is a key factor in determining how effectively a message is delivered.


The Constitutional Court has consistently applied strict standards to restrictions on rally locations. In December 2022, the Constitutional Court ruled that the provision of the Assembly and Demonstration Act, which imposed a blanket ban on rallies near the presidential residence, was unconstitutional. The Court stated, "When citizens wish to convey their opinions to the President through rallies, the area near the presidential residence is the place where those opinions can be most effectively delivered," and added, "A comprehensive and uniform ban on rallies near the presidential residence restricts the core aspect of the freedom of assembly." Furthermore, the Court pointed out that "it is difficult to justify banning all rallies near the presidential residence solely based on the abstract assumption that there may be a risk of violence, illegality, or unexpected incidents." The same principle has been applied in previous Constitutional Court decisions regarding bans on rallies near diplomatic institutions in 2003, and near the National Assembly, the Prime Minister's residence, and courts at all levels in 2018.


What the police currently take issue with is not specific risks but the nature and past record of the rally. This is highly likely to lead to selective intervention in freedom of expression. Restricting the route simply because the statements of a particular group are controversial results in a preemptive, censorious effect on the core elements of assembly. The criteria for determining what constitutes hate are also unclear. What defines hate, and at what level friction is expected, ultimately depends on the subjective judgment of the police. Any restriction of fundamental rights must have clarity and predictability. If march routes are restricted based on abstract concepts, the freedom of assembly itself may eventually be undermined.


The police's duty is to take action after the fact when a clear danger arises on site and to maintain public order. If rallies begin to be preemptively blocked, constitutional values can be curtailed at any time for administrative convenience. The repeated warnings in Constitutional Court precedents are precisely about the dangers of preemptive and sweeping restrictions. The statement by Acting Commissioner General Yoo clearly reveals a perspective of public authority that regards rallies as objects of control rather than protection. True democracy is proven by the patience to leave even uncomfortable expressions in the public forum.



[Right of Reply] Regarding the article 「[Editor's Note] Constitutional Question Raised by Acting Police Commissioner」
Our media outlet reported on December 19 last year in the article titled 「[Editor's Note] Constitutional Question Raised by Acting Police Commissioner」 that the hate rally response plan of Yoo Jaesung, Acting Commissioner General of the Korean National Police Agency, posed a significant risk to constitutional values.

In response, the National Police Agency informed us: “The police prioritize constitutional values such as the freedom of assembly, association, and expression in all rallies and demonstrations, and maintain a balance between rights protection and public order in accordance with the Assembly and Demonstration Act. What Acting Commissioner General Yoo stated at the press briefing was that, in locations with many merchants and tourists, if there is concern about collective clashes due to hate speech, the march route may be partially restricted. Such measures have been reviewed and approved by the National Police Commission, and the courts have also determined that they are not excessive restrictions.”

This statement is made in accordance with a settlement by the Press Arbitration Commission.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing