Five-Year Legal Battle With Information System Contractors Ends in Final Defeat
Ministry Ordered to Compensate CJ OliveNetworks and KCC Information & Communication

The Ministry of National Defense has been ordered to pay over 50 billion won in compensation to domestic information and communications companies. The ministry continued its lawsuit against CJ OliveNetworks and KCC Information & Communication, which had won the bid for the "Army·Navy·Air Force Logistics Information System Integration Project," but ultimately lost in the final appeal. As a result, the ministry will have to pay not only the principal amount but also late payment interest, all funded by taxpayers.


According to government officials on December 12, the Civil Division 1 of the Supreme Court dismissed the Ministry of National Defense's appeal in the unjust enrichment lawsuit the previous day, without proceeding to a full hearing. This type of dismissal means the court found no grounds for the appeal based solely on written records, without additional hearings. The confirmed compensation amount set by the Supreme Court is approximately 45.6 billion won. With the appeal dismissed, the ministry is now expected to pay over 50 billion won, including late payment interest.


Ministry of National Defense to Pay 50 Billion Won in Compensation from Taxpayer Funds View original image


The dispute began in 2015, when the Ministry of National Defense commissioned the "Army·Navy·Air Force Logistics Information System Integration Project" worth 25 billion won. The project aimed to unify the separate logistics information systems operated by the Army, Navy, and Air Force into a single system. The project was scheduled to run for 35 months, from December 2015 to November 2018. A consortium comprising CJ OliveNetworks, KCC Information & Communication, and Pentacreed won the contract, with ten related small and medium-sized software companies participating.

Ministry of National Defense to Pay 50 Billion Won in Compensation from Taxpayer Funds View original image

However, according to the companies, the scope of work nearly doubled compared to the original contract, as each branch of the military demanded system development tailored to their unique requirements. The companies requested additional compensation from the ministry for the increased workload, but their requests were denied. Instead, the ministry imposed liquidated damages on the companies, citing project delays.



Some companies faced financial difficulties due to these liquidated damages. Pentacreed, the lead company of the consortium, withdrew from the project in 2017. It is also reported that software company Datacore recently decided to withdraw from the project. Ultimately, CJ OliveNetworks and KCC Information & Communication filed a lawsuit against the ministry five years ago, arguing that the ministry added work during the project without providing proper compensation and instead imposed liquidated damages. Three years after the lawsuit was filed, the court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in the first trial in January last year, and the same verdict was delivered in the second trial held a year and six months later in August this year.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing