[The Editors' Verdict] The Goals of SME Funding Support Must Be Redefined View original image

The recent report by the Bank of Korea, which highlights issues in the funding support system for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), deserves closer attention. Titled "Current Status of Korean SMEs and Proposals for Improving Support Systems," the report argues that support recipients should be selected based on productivity and future value, rather than simply on sales figures. In other words, more resources should be poured into promising new ventures rather than into "bottomless pits." The backdrop to this argument is the reality that, due to inadequate restructuring systems, failing companies are unable to exit in a timely manner, becoming so-called "zombie firms" that survive for as long as possible by relying on nearly 35 trillion won annually in support.


As of 2022, the ratio of policy finance to Korea's gross domestic product (GDP) stood at 5.8%, far exceeding the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) average of 1.4%. However, the effectiveness of this support is limited, and most of the benefits are short-lived, peaking in the first year. From the second or third year of support, productivity and profits actually decline. This is a serious issue, even when considering the inevitable welfare function of such policies. It is therefore urgent to redefine the focus of SME support-whether it should be on welfare and relief, or on fostering the industrial ecosystem and creating a virtuous cycle-by finding a new balance based on these discussions.

Structuring for Fostering and Virtuous Cycles

Such criticism is not new. Policymakers are well aware of the limitations of the current system. Nevertheless, it is difficult to even get these discussions on track due to the political hurdles inherent in policy design. No government is willing to make decisions such as reducing guarantees or restructuring failing companies, due to concerns about the short-term impact on local economies. Internal evaluation practices at guarantee and financial institutions, which focus on "continuing existing support and defending against future defaults," also play a significant role. In this environment, it is almost inevitable that policy objectives become blurred and meaningless capital injections are repeated.


Research and development (R&D) capabilities, patent portfolios, and potential for global expansion are the true core indicators for assessing SME value, yet the current support system still emphasizes evaluations similar to traditional loan screenings based on past performance. In stark contrast to the venture investment ecosystem, where money flows to "high-growth but cash-poor" companies, the policy system channels funds to "cash-rich but low-growth" firms. This shows that the market and policy are speaking entirely different languages. As a result, innovative companies that should be supported by the market must pay higher costs to raise capital, while a significant portion of policy funds is spent keeping failing firms afloat-creating a structural mismatch.

Weighing the Opportunity Cost of Conventional Support

The report suggests that reallocating funds to highly productive but relatively young and low-revenue companies could increase Korea's total economic output by about 0.45%. In other words, the current system incurs that much in opportunity costs. Of course, the risks of selective support should not be overlooked. Because it is difficult to predict outcomes, government support could become overly concentrated on certain groups of companies, and there is also the possibility of creating a "policy stigma."



This is why a data-driven evaluation system, integration of private sector expertise, and adoption of market-validated indicators are needed. Experiments such as linking artificial intelligence (AI)-based financial analysis with patent data analysis are worth considering. Is there any reason to resist concepts like selection, focus, and concentration? If this approach can create a broader foundation for growth, that in itself is a public good and a future strategy.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing