A Leap in Justifying Martial Law Under the Pretext of National Crisis
Abuse of Power Against the People Must Never Be Allowed
The Minimum Standard of Democracy We Must Leave to Our Children

[Inside Chodong] Yoon's Red Card and the Minimum Standard of Democracy View original image

A virtual TV debate stage. The moderator asks, "To the current and former presidents: What kind of day was December 3, 2024?"


President Lee Jaemyung speaks first. "It was the day an illegal praetorian coup began, and also the day the people, with nothing but their bare hands, peacefully stopped that coup." Former President Yoon Sukyeol argues, "It was a resolute fulfillment of the constitutional duty to defend the nation against an attempt to paralyze state affairs and overthrow the liberal constitutional order." He explains, "I appealed to the people through emergency martial law in the face of 30 personnel impeachments by a dictatorial parliament, budget cuts, potential vote-count hacking, and a country overrun by spies."


President Lee responds, "It was the people who blocked the armored vehicles headed for the National Assembly with their bodies and opened a path over the barricaded walls of the Assembly." He adds, "It was not the president's emergency powers, but the people, the National Assembly, the courts, and the military who upheld the Constitution and the law and restored constitutional order." He declares, "I will designate December 3 as 'National Sovereignty Day.'" When former President Yoon counters, "The reckless rampage of an unjust dictatorship trying to seize control of the judiciary continues. I urge the people to show them the red card," President Lee firmly responds, "Completing the 'Revolution of Light' means building systems and a culture that make it impossible to even dream of another coup."


This virtual debate is a near-verbatim reenactment of the special statements and prison messages released by the two presidents on the first anniversary of the martial law. The logic of former President Yoon (or his supporters) remains unchanged. They have failed to move beyond the starting point of 'breaking through falsehoods and revealing the truth.'


Their arguments rest on three main points. First, they defined the numerous personnel impeachments, budget cuts, and legislative disputes at the time as 'paralyzing state affairs' and 'attempting to overthrow the system.' However, these are powers granted to the National Assembly by the Constitution and fall within the normal workings of democracy. In fact, it was the decision to impose emergency martial law-branding the Assembly as 'forces undermining the constitutional order' and mobilizing the military, police, and intelligence agencies-that truly put constitutional order to the test.


The narrative of 'parliamentary dictatorship' also persists. The opposition-party president who won the 2022 regime change was impeached for declaring martial law to strengthen his power, lost the presidency, and is now on trial for insurrection. Can the functioning of such institutional checks and balances really be called 'dictatorship'? In reality, the shadow of dictatorship grew much darker the moment the president branded the parliament that checked his power as 'anti-state forces' and brought in the military.


On the early morning of December 2, one day before the first anniversary of the December 12 emergency martial law incident, a light was lit on the symbolic stone in front of the National Assembly main building. 2025.12.2 Photo by Kim Hyunmin

On the early morning of December 2, one day before the first anniversary of the December 12 emergency martial law incident, a light was lit on the symbolic stone in front of the National Assembly main building. 2025.12.2 Photo by Kim Hyunmin

View original image

They also lumped together issues of very different natures to create what they called a 'total crisis.' Budget cuts, election management vulnerabilities, and espionage cases are each serious issues, but claiming that all of these justified emergency martial law is a leap in logic. As Harvard Professor Steven Levitsky wrote in his book "How Democracies Die," "Democracy is slowly destroyed by elected leaders who exaggerate crises and normalize states of exception." Former President Yoon seems unable to realize that 'martial law declared by a president with a gun' can never overcome 'the people holding glow sticks.'



I hope that, as time passes, we will be able to tell our children, "Back then, the president declared martial law, but the people, the National Assembly, and the courts reversed it. That is why your generation lives in a country where you never have to fear such a night again." For this to happen, there is only one principle: under no circumstances should the red card of martial law against the sovereign people ever be shown again. That is the minimum standard of democracy we must leave for our children.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing