"SME Policy Fund Support: Changing Selection Criteria Alone Can Boost Korea's Total Output by Up to 0.7%"
Bank of Korea Releases In-depth Mid- to Long-term Study
SME Support Has Increased, but Impact Remains Limited
Support Criteria Focused on Sa

According to a recent study, if the criteria for supporting small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) with policy funds-currently focused on sales and assets-are shifted to prioritize productivity, South Korea's total output could increase by up to 0.7% without expanding the scale of support.


On December 8, the Bank of Korea announced these findings in its report, "In-depth Mid- to Long-term Study: The Current Status of Korean SMEs and Policy Support System Improvement Measures." The report was authored by Jang Geunho, Director of the Macroeconomic Research Division at the Bank of Korea Economic Research Institute, and Choi Kisang, Head of the Macroeconomic Research Team.


South Korea's SME policy has been centered on policy financing, with the scale of support continuously expanding, making it substantial in quantitative terms. As of last year, the budget for SME-related projects executed by the government and local governments amounted to approximately 34.5 trillion won, with 1,761 support programs in place. The policy fund managed by the Ministry of SMEs and Startups has increased 5.4 times compared to 1997, and credit guarantees have grown 7.8 times. Both the scale of SME support and the level of policy intervention in South Korea are high by international standards. In 2022, the share of policy finance relative to GDP was 5.8%, significantly higher than the OECD average of 1.4%.

"SME Policy Fund Support: Changing Selection Criteria Alone Could Boost Korea's Total Output by Up to 0.7%" View original image

While the quantitative outcomes are clear, the report pointed out that there are distinct limitations in terms of productivity and dynamism. According to the Bank of Korea’s empirical analysis, policy support has been effective in promoting external growth, such as increased sales and reduced closure rates, as well as short-term survival. However, its effect on improving productivity and profitability, or on expanding the foundation for mid- to long-term growth such as facility investment, has been limited. When government support increased by 1%, capital productivity and return on assets (ROA) showed improvement only in the first year, with no significant effect observed in the second and third years. In monetary terms, when government support per company increased by 100 million won, capital productivity decreased by approximately 0.31%, and ROA fell by 0.038 percentage points. Facility investment also declined by about 3.32 million won per 100 million won of government support on average per year.


The Bank of Korea noted that these limitations are closely linked to structural issues in the design of SME support systems. Support recipients are selected based on sales, a metric with little correlation to productivity, and the qualification criteria for SMEs have become a threshold that separates firms eligible for government support and regulation, leading to companies avoiding growth. Additionally, the lack of an adequate restructuring system for SMEs has prevented the timely exit of insolvent firms, contributing to the inefficient allocation of government support.


Based on its analysis, the Bank of Korea concluded that addressing these structural limitations-by changing "who and how to support" rather than increasing the scale of support-could boost total output by approximately 0.4% to 0.7%.


Specifically, if the support criteria are shifted from sales to business age, and funds are redistributed to younger, high-productivity firms (those in business for seven years or less), total output would increase by 0.45%. This figure includes a 0.06% effect from alleviating the "Peter Pan syndrome," in which SMEs avoid transitioning to mid-sized companies. Furthermore, if the overall efficiency of restructuring is improved to levels similar to those in the United States and Japan, total output would rise by 0.23%, and the proportion of marginal firms would decrease by 0.23 percentage points.



Choi Kisang stated, "Going forward, SME support systems should be supplemented to enhance productivity and dynamism by improving the selection of recipients and incentive structures, rather than simply increasing the number of support programs or the size of the budget." He added, "Instead of focusing on sales and assets, core selection criteria should be productivity and innovation capabilities, and the private sector’s evaluation and investment capabilities should be actively utilized." He also emphasized, "Complementary indicators such as business age, which do not induce the Peter Pan syndrome, should be used in parallel," and "The restructuring system should be improved to enable early identification of insolvency, autonomous adjustment, and orderly exit."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing